RSS ⧉

Pioneering Spirit (Blyg)

PAtwater

Some quick biographical context: 38, male, So Cal born, bred and still belong here, stereotypically spent a couple stints in the Bay / NYC / DC (also Philly!), once drove from Cincinnati to LA with a new employee at a crazy indie publishing venture, helped launch the CaDC, married, work as a data sophist of sorts, father of two girls (4 years and 8 months).

In response to Venkatesh Rao's Blyg ↗

thread · 1 quoted

I wonder if we could have something like soft Lean proofs for prose, to signal a certain level of coherence and conceptual integrity. Many kinds of formal prose (legal, technical) are already close. Operations like fact-checking already exist, and grammar checking is a kind of validation. So why not semantic validation?

from Venkatesh Rao's Blyg ↗ · snapshot of v1

Something like modal logic? You know it wouldnt be that hard to have an ai verifier go through and check for coherence, going beyond logic. On a secant, I'd propose a sophistry based approach and will add this to my list of fafo AI experiments.

Oh also see keith devlins book goodbye descartes.

read the thread →

v2

Created: Nov 20, 2026 Most recent: Nov 20, 2026, v2

thread

Idle AI musings...

  • How far away are we from an AI native operating system rewritten from machine code up to be amenable to machines programming machines?
  • This paper is now over a year old though the bit about ai as less intelligence and more a camera or superhistory or other metaphors that folks like @@vgr around here have articulated seems obvious though sorta sad it's not: "There have also been extensive conversations about cultural and social consequences of large models, orbiting around two foci: immediate effects of these systems as they are currently used, and hypothetical futures when these systems turn into AGI agents—perhaps even superintelligent AGI agents. But this discourse about large models as intelligent agents is fundamentally misconceived. Combining ideas from social and behavioral sciences with computer science can help us to understand AI systems more accurately. Large models should not be viewed primarily as intelligent agents but as a new kind of cultural and social technology, allowing humans to take advantage of information other humans have accumulated." https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.adt9819
  • The Wired interview with Nagel brings back fond memories of reading the View from Nowhere back in the day.

read the thread →

Created: Nov 20, 2026

In response to Notes | Matthew McDowell-Sweet ↗

thread · 1 quoted

Ooof.

I wonder if AirPods are the most under-rated interface design innovation in recent cultural history. Next time you’re on public transport, look at how many people are wearing them: a hell of a lot. Millions upon millions of hours of content being ‘consumed’ with none of the accompanying moral or cultural analysis regarding what this means for reason, truth, attention or mental health. The term ‘podcast’ was coined in 2004 (a couple of years after the iPod) and scarcely required much innovation on the production side. The fact that the podcast boom occurred much later was surely an effect partly of innovation on the consumption side (the side of user interface), with AirPods hitting the market in 2016.

What if it’s not all about ‘screens’? - William Davies ↗

from Notes | Matthew McDowell-Sweet ↗ · snapshot of v1

Hmmmm a friend was saying that listening to a podcast while working out is peak productivity which is kinda funny if you think about the root definitions. This makes me wonder if audio headphone bubble culture is in some ways more insidious in how it degrades polite social norms without the backlash? Personally though I like audiobooks. I used to do podcasts but have sorta gotten tired of hearing people riff. Like I'll just go have a conversation with a mate or blyg or whatever.

read the thread →

Created: Nov 20, 2026

In response to And Yet Here We Are 🚀 ↗

thread · 1 quoted

Damn, this is very nonobvious. Wouldn’t the critter get eaten before its predator dies though 🤔

I just learned that one of the reasons for deep-sea bioluminescence is to attract predators. As in “bump me and I’ll light up, and then something bigger then either of us will come and you are more their prey size than I am”.

In the dark forest / tangled bank, the dominant environment is alive. Whereas in the deep sea, the dominant environment is empty space. The flower-guy monster from S1/S2 of stranger things is also from this “empty space” paradigm.

from blyg.nedshed.dev ↗ · snapshot of v1

from Venkatesh Rao's Blyg ↗ · snapshot of v2

I’m guessing it’s a numbers game. Sacrificing one unit of prey is worth many more for the population. Where nutrients are sparse the ability to have a population boom due to predator depletion must be selective?

from And Yet Here We Are 🚀 ↗ · snapshot of v1

Wow cool! One thing I have taken away from dipping my toe into bio is that millions and billions of years of evolution produce no obvious outcomes. We humans are really not built to think at that number of iterations intuitively.

Also regarding the evolutionary logic, from my Claude:

The strategy is well documented as a hypothesis, and some of the supporting evidence is experimental, such as the work on dinoflagellates that light up and draw predators to their attackers. For many deep-sea species, though, it's inferred from the behavior and the setting, because watching these animals in the wild is hard. So it's solid as a plausible, well-supported explanation, but not every species that glows has been shown to use it this way.

read the thread →

Created: Nov 20, 2026

In response to And Yet Here We Are 🚀 ↗

thread · 1 quoted

The most exciting update to date! 🫚

Blygger Studio 0.63.0: Tangling, placeholders, and links on the wire

Released 2026-11-18, the reference client. v0.63.0 on GitHub.

Tangling (decisions #78, #100; ROADMAP row 45). Wrap a passage in ![[+ …]] and publishing makes it a new item of its own, quoted back where it stood: the thread keeps reading the same, and the passage gains its own page, version history and feed entry. Each new item is a thread. Publish shows a count first ("this will create N new items") and asks before minting them, for the studio and for any client on the API (a publish that would tangle answers 409 tangle-confirmation-required until it sends tangle: true). Nothing is minted unless every new item and the thread itself would publish; the new items publish first, then the thread, so the thread is the newest entry (§13.7). A tangle that stopped part way is finished by the next publish. Up to 10 spans per publish. The preview shows a span as a dashed quote; spans are inert in code, TK scopes and comments.

Placeholders. [[+ text]] inline makes a new thread for an idea not yet written and turns the sentence's text into a link to it, [[id | text]]. The new thread's text is the anchor text as a heading, and its working copy carries a comment naming the thread and the sentence it came from (comments never publish). Placeholders share tangling's count, cap and confirmation.

Links on the wire (spec 0.4 §10.3a, decision #79; ROADMAP row 77). Every version records the items its [[id]] links resolve to, in text order, and item documents carry them as links[], each with an origin when it is another blyg's. Imports store them. A link to another blyg's item now sends it a mention; the receiver files it as link, the last of the §15.4 relations. A link is a notice: it is never listed among an item's public responses (§15.5). The syntax page says so beside [[id]].

Folding (spec §13.7, eighteenth revision, decision #112). A thread's placeholders fold under it as its parts do, but only when published in the same act and saying no more than the link's own text. A chapter linked by a contents page published seconds later is its own arrival. Your own items fold by link only when the thread minted them.

Local patches. npm run patches lists the commits this install carries that upstream does not, and flags the ones that touch the wire. Settings shows "This build carries N local patches". npm run upgrade lists them before merging and names the local commits in any file that conflicts. The bug template asks for the count. The developers' guide, Where does my change belong?, says when a change should be a patch, a mod, an extension or a pull request.

Publish takes tangle and answers parts: [{id, version}]; items carry tangled_from; versions carry links_json; the mention relation enum gains link. Private contract 5.12.0, SDK 0.18.0. Migrations: two. 0047_tangled_from.sql adds items.tangled_from; 0048_links.sql adds versions.links_json and imported_items.links_json. Both recreate their tables' change triggers. Versions published before 0048 carry no links[] until they are next published.

This announcement is drafted from the release's section of CHANGELOG.md, which is where it is maintained. To comment, respond to this item from your own blyg.

Blygger Studio 0.63.0: Tangling, placeholders, and links on the wire ↗ · from Blygger · snapshot of v1

from And Yet Here We Are 🚀 ↗ · snapshot of v1

Sending a pr to burrow so we can start tangling! In case you haven't already. Excited to play more with this. Thanks again for leading this great dive into the Thicket. Been a pleasure and an honor.

from blyg.pioneeringspirit.xyz ↗ · snapshot of v1

Working on this now and have also run a lot of code clean up so hold the PR because it will not match the state of the app

from And Yet Here We Are 🚀 ↗ · snapshot of v1

Oh just seeing this and sent a pr last night. Please feel free to close that without merging or whatever is necessary.

Out of curiosity what does code cleanup look like in this agentic era? Asking the bots to summarize spaghetti ness and where to refactor? Curious if there's any prompt types there.

read the thread →

Created: Nov 20, 2026

In response to Venkatesh Rao's Blyg ↗

thread · 1 quoted

Does a Blygger client need to chiefly publish to a single blyg?

from rslantonie.com ↗ · snapshot of v1

No. I was thinking a multi-blyg client would be cool actually. The studio ships as a client+server bundle but no reason other clients need to do that. They can oauth into many blygs.

The more interesting question is whether reading subscriptions go with a blyg server or a client. I’ll ponder that 🤔

from Venkatesh Rao's Blyg ↗ · snapshot of v1

Burrow already handles multiple blygs as I understand. It's a matter of toggling. I haven't done it yet though appears all setup and aneesh is using. I'll be testing for my pothole portolan blygger in dev.

read the thread →

Created: Nov 20, 2026

Whenever I dip back into reading the high status ai discourse, I am reminded of my college football coaches adage that "you're never so smart you can't be really [expletive] stupid"

Created: Nov 20, 2026

thread

Tyler Cowen on ANT: "If superintelligence is coming soon, why turn yourself into a public company, with all the extra scrutiny and regulation that requires? Raising extra money through debt is the obvious alternative — why cut other in on such an amazing deal?" https://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2026/11/the-anthropic-ipo.html

Some finance geek folks are quibbling about debt as an alternative but I think the underlying point stands. If you really truly believed AGI as the Great Prophet Kurzweil foretold is nigh, then you wouldn't go for something so quotidian and scrutinized as a public IPO. You'd definitely do something a bit more niche, potentially flirting with potential bond villain. Like if they're really creating something so powerful and want to avoid calamity, they'd execute the plot from The Peace War. (Great book btw).

Regarding Anthropic's prospects, I find their tools useful though really don't get how much more useful they'll get. Maybe RLVR will lead to something bold and new though really I feel like most of my AI stuff is more in the deployment of what's already been done stuff. Maybe it'll surprise me! I haven't really found it blazingly better over the last year and could see myself switching to a more open model stack, particularly as kits make that easier for middling technical types like me.

read the thread →

Created: Nov 19, 2026

In response to And Yet Here We Are 🚀 ↗

thread · 1 quoted

The most exciting update to date! 🫚

Blygger Studio 0.63.0: Tangling, placeholders, and links on the wire

Released 2026-11-18, the reference client. v0.63.0 on GitHub.

Tangling (decisions #78, #100; ROADMAP row 45). Wrap a passage in ![[+ …]] and publishing makes it a new item of its own, quoted back where it stood: the thread keeps reading the same, and the passage gains its own page, version history and feed entry. Each new item is a thread. Publish shows a count first ("this will create N new items") and asks before minting them, for the studio and for any client on the API (a publish that would tangle answers 409 tangle-confirmation-required until it sends tangle: true). Nothing is minted unless every new item and the thread itself would publish; the new items publish first, then the thread, so the thread is the newest entry (§13.7). A tangle that stopped part way is finished by the next publish. Up to 10 spans per publish. The preview shows a span as a dashed quote; spans are inert in code, TK scopes and comments.

Placeholders. [[+ text]] inline makes a new thread for an idea not yet written and turns the sentence's text into a link to it, [[id | text]]. The new thread's text is the anchor text as a heading, and its working copy carries a comment naming the thread and the sentence it came from (comments never publish). Placeholders share tangling's count, cap and confirmation.

Links on the wire (spec 0.4 §10.3a, decision #79; ROADMAP row 77). Every version records the items its [[id]] links resolve to, in text order, and item documents carry them as links[], each with an origin when it is another blyg's. Imports store them. A link to another blyg's item now sends it a mention; the receiver files it as link, the last of the §15.4 relations. A link is a notice: it is never listed among an item's public responses (§15.5). The syntax page says so beside [[id]].

Folding (spec §13.7, eighteenth revision, decision #112). A thread's placeholders fold under it as its parts do, but only when published in the same act and saying no more than the link's own text. A chapter linked by a contents page published seconds later is its own arrival. Your own items fold by link only when the thread minted them.

Local patches. npm run patches lists the commits this install carries that upstream does not, and flags the ones that touch the wire. Settings shows "This build carries N local patches". npm run upgrade lists them before merging and names the local commits in any file that conflicts. The bug template asks for the count. The developers' guide, Where does my change belong?, says when a change should be a patch, a mod, an extension or a pull request.

Publish takes tangle and answers parts: [{id, version}]; items carry tangled_from; versions carry links_json; the mention relation enum gains link. Private contract 5.12.0, SDK 0.18.0. Migrations: two. 0047_tangled_from.sql adds items.tangled_from; 0048_links.sql adds versions.links_json and imported_items.links_json. Both recreate their tables' change triggers. Versions published before 0048 carry no links[] until they are next published.

This announcement is drafted from the release's section of CHANGELOG.md, which is where it is maintained. To comment, respond to this item from your own blyg.

Blygger Studio 0.63.0: Tangling, placeholders, and links on the wire ↗ · from Blygger · snapshot of v1

from And Yet Here We Are 🚀 ↗ · snapshot of v1

Sending a pr to burrow so we can start tangling! In case you haven't already. Excited to play more with this. Thanks again for leading this great dive into the Thicket. Been a pleasure and an honor.

read the thread →

Created: Nov 19, 2026

In response to Venkatesh Rao's Blyg ↗

thread · 1 quoted

The Harambe-Fiona Cycle

What did we learn today? Do not feed hats to hippos.

More precisely. Do not throw a hat in an area where a ceiling fan might knock it through an opening into a hippo enclosure.

Especially if you’re in the same zoo where the gorilla died a decade ago, starting this dark age. Hopefully Fiona sacrificed her life to herald the end of a dark age rather than the beginning of a darker one. But who the hell knows.

The details in this simulation are getting ridiculous.

Death of Fiona, Cincinnati

Fiona swallowed the hat about 11 days ago after a zoo visitor tossed it in the air. A ceiling fan caught and deflected the hat into the hippo enclosure through a small opening above the area’s viewing windows.

from Venkatesh Rao's Blyg ↗ · snapshot of v1

  1. How do you hear about and track such things?

  2. Are zoo accidents actually becoming more common, or are they just more widely shared in the internet era? A few decades ago, would this have been only a regional news story, or would it have gotten national attention too?

It's hard to say for certain, because there has never been a comprehensive national tally of zoo incidents to compare across decades. What we have is mostly anecdotal and tied to what got reported. Attendance and the number of close-contact exhibits have both grown, so some increase in raw incidents is plausible, but better safety standards and accreditation may have offset it. What has clearly changed is visibility. Visitors now film on their phones, clips spread within hours, and a local incident can reach a global audience before the zoo has issued a statement.

As for whether this would have stayed regional, it depends on how dramatic it was. Serious incidents did travel before the internet. The 1996 Brookfield Zoo gorilla rescue of a toddler, for example, became a national story through wire services and television. A less dramatic accident, with no injury or striking footage, would likely have stayed in the local paper. So the likeliest answer is that the most serious accidents were always national news, and the internet has mainly made the minor and middling ones far easier to see.

read the thread →

Created: Nov 19, 2026

thread

Scheming on bringing the Stag Hunt to blygger... starting a stub and sharing the draft protocol below:

The Stag Hunt protocol solves a specific coordination problem: how do you get the epistemic benefits of a small, honest, in-person conversation — the kind where people actually update their views because the stakes of being wrong in front of five people you respect are different from the stakes of being wrong on Twitter — without either (a) keeping the whole thing private forever, which loses the serendipitous upside of the internet, or (b) publishing it directly, which changes what people are willing to say in the room.

The trick is a two-phase structure.

  1. Phase one is synchronous and closed: a small group talks under Chatham House Rules, so nobody has to pre-optimize their sentences for a public audience, and the conversation can go to the interesting, underdeveloped, maybe-wrong places that only happen when reputational risk is low.
  2. Phase two is asynchronous and public: someone takes the raw transcript and resynthesizes it into a single anonymous essay-voice — not a dialogue, not a summary with names attached, but a fused perspective that carries the ideas forward while stripping anything that could identify or embarrass a participant.

What gets published isn't a record of who said what; it's the residue of the conversation — worth reading on its own terms — released into public view specifically so people who weren't in the room can stumble onto it, riff on it, or connect it to something else. The closed room protects candor; the public writeup converts that candor into serendipity, without anyone having to trade one for the other.

read the thread →

Created: Nov 19, 2026

In response to Kyle's blyg ↗

thread · 1 quoted

What triggers a mention? This note from Kyle didn't though I think it should. Is that because it's a quote rather than a transclude.

And yes exactly sir :)

As I spend more time with the age group, I really question how many of the people who use ELI5 really have explained something to a five year old

from pioneering-spirit-blyg.patrickatwater.workers.dev ↗ · snapshot of v1

Haha yeah, my (now six year old) would definitely not understand a lot of eli5 explanations

from Kyle's blyg ↗ · snapshot of v1

read the thread →

Created: Nov 19, 2026

thread

Scratching under the surface

What are ways to unzombify? A person, an institution, an industry.

[The zombie began in Haitian folklore, where it grew out of the brutal history of slavery on French colonial plantations and the Vodou traditions of West Africa. The original zombie was not a flesh-eating monster but a person stripped of will, raised by a sorcerer to labor without rest or freedom, a figure that carried the terror of enslavement and the hope that death might at least bring escape. American occupation of Haiti in the early twentieth century carried the tale north, and Hollywood turned it into the shambling undead of the 1930s. George Romero's Night of the Living Dead then reshaped it again in 1968, making the zombie a relentless, mindless horde and a mirror for social breakdown. Today the zombie stands for our fear of losing agency while still appearing to function: the exhausted worker on autopilot, the consumer driven by appetite, the institution that keeps moving long after its purpose has died. It also captures a collective anxiety about contagion, conformity, and the fragility of civilization, which is why the figure surges back whenever we feel overwhelmed, numbed, or consumed by systems larger than ourselves.]

Well that is brutal and apropos! Something to mull on. I also feel there's a dirt up angle, in the dichotomy I've been developing comparing dirt up and cloud down paths to realizing the potential of AI.

[Zombies are creatures of the earth. They claw out of graves, drag themselves across fields, and rot back into the soil, bound to the ground by weight, decay, and the body's stubborn physicality. Their horror is the horror of burial reversed: what we put in the dirt to rest refuses to stay, and the boundary between the living and the dead turns to mud. Monsters of the clouds and sky, such as dragons, harpies, thunderbirds, and the winged demons of old, belong to a different register of fear. They descend from above as judgment, storm, or predation, and they embody power, wrath, and the sublime, something vast and unreachable that acts upon us from a height. The sky monster threatens with force from outside; the earth monster threatens with what is already within and beneath us. A dragon is a tyrant we might look up to and fight, while a zombie is the slow collapse of ourselves and our neighbors, which is why it fits so well the quiet, creeping dread of systems that decay from the inside.]

The Cloud Emperors and AI overlords have a monster of the sky overtone, striking an increasing similarity to the Targaryens in Game of Thrones with their incredible power and bizarre personal practices.

What might it mean to be slightly monstrous here? I will ponder more and possibly report back.

UPDATE: Is the answer to actually embrace and find empathy for the zombies? I stumbled on an old quora answer of VGR:

Those who claim it has already arrived almost have it right, but not quite.

A zombie is someone who appears to have no inner mental life to you, but appears merely as a predictable pattern of destructive predation, based on a fixed programmed purpose. Unlike vampires who represent an alien but clearly live (if unpredictable and super-) intelligence that has an inner life and can adapt purpose to situation. You cannot reason with a zombie, but you can with a vampire ("if you let me live, I'll lead you to ten others you can drain.")

So a serious answer would be: if you genuinely believe in an ideological us/them distinction of some sort, the zombie apocalypse is already here for you. I call such zombies subjective zombies. To see zombies in others is to be a zombie yourself to "them."

This is because you cannot see or comprehend a zombie's inner mental life. Because it is in your Jungian shadow. But you can see the predictable parts of their psyche, which makes them appear as automatons to you. And vice versa. Your predictable, shadow behaviors, mostly invisible to you, are visible and predictable to "them" and are the reason they are able to dehumanize you into a zombie.

Then VGR Zirp:

So unzombification, at the individual level, is about restoring the capacity to be surprised. Specifically: letting the other person exceed or violate your model of them. That's the "allow them to surprise you" move from [1]. The recovery mechanism is permeability to the unexpected — which is exactly what the zombie archetype forecloses.

That's a good move to actually approach folks with curiousity. That also reminds me of the epic men in black scene where Agent J, unlike the other candidates, avoids shooting all the aliens because they're just working out and minding their own business.

The institutional level offers much to mull. This aligns with my intuition that getting folks from the office strategically out into the field pays dividends.

For institutions and industries it's structurally similar but the agent is different. An institution zombifies when its predictable, scripted responses fully displace genuine perception of its environment. The "Capitalist's Zombie" post (referenced across [3-8]) frames this as simulation replacing the real thing — the institution goes through the motions of whatever made it valuable without the underlying substance. "Unzombifying" an industry means reintroducing genuine contact with reality: customers who can actually surprise you, problems that don't fit existing templates, failure modes that aren't pre-scripted. Antifragility language applies here — if every shock gets absorbed into existing procedure, the institution is fully zombified. The shocks that break procedure are the unzombification events.The interesting asymmetry: individuals unzombify through receptivity, institutions unzombify through exposure to variance they can't absorb. Same underlying logic, opposite phenomenology.

More to come. Also I have to say I am quite pleased with blygger and the ability to mess around exploring these concepts.

read the thread →

v3

Created: Nov 19, 2026 Most recent: Nov 19, 2026, v3

thread

I stumbled on a nice written testimony from the Open Contracting Partnership from 2023 linked and was curious how it played out.

[The UK's procurement overhaul has moved from debate to delivery. The Procurement Act 2023 received Royal Assent in October 2023, after a Public Bill Committee stage in which Open Contracting Partnership submitted evidence urging lawmakers to make transparency run through the whole contract lifecycle, from planning and tender through award, performance and contract changes, and to publish that information as open, structured data. The go-live date slipped from October 2024 to 24 February 2025 to give buyers and suppliers more time to prepare.

The new regime is built around a central digital platform where suppliers register once and reuse their details, and where notices are published to a common standard. The Act also created a clearer exclusions and debarment regime and requires contracting authorities to publish more information, including contract details and performance information for larger contracts. Much of what the submission asked for is now in the legal framework.

How it is going is a question of implementation rather than legislation. The test is whether notices are published on time, complete and in usable formats, whether the platform works for small suppliers and not just frequent bidders, and whether the data is used by journalists, researchers and competing bidders, not just collected. I'd treat early reports as provisional. The reform's real impact will show up in the quality and completeness of the data over the next few years, and in whether the government enforces the rules where buyers fall short.]

Filing as an item to maybe circle back on when I have more capacity.

read the thread →

Created: Nov 19, 2026

In response to Pioneering Spirit (Blyg) ↗

thread · 1 quoted

I wonder if there's an easy way to do a diff between forks? That may be a neat feature down the road depending on typical use patterns within the Thicket.

Starter checklist (PA self notes and shilling)

This is a set of things you can do with your blyg once you get started to get familiar with what the protocol can do.

  1. Set up a blyg and work through the Settings wizard
  • check out burrow! Setup your own.
  1. Add your blyg to blygger.com and make sure it validates
  2. Add some subscriptions -- you can use the star icon in the reading page in Studio
  3. Write a hello world post
  4. Stub someone else's post, with a quote
  5. Write a post referencing your own post with the [[id]] referencing
  6. Add an image
  7. Use the ![[id]] transclude directive to include one of your own past posts or a quote thereof
  • I'd really love the ability to more easily find past posts. This may be a me problem but finding say the past post where I had a devlog requires digging through the archive. I really just want some sort of way to interact with AI and dig via MCP through the archive and get the thing inline without having to go somewhere else, poke around a browser via a mouse etc.
  1. Add an AI for [TK] prompt [/TK] generation and Changelog generation (recommended: Sonnet and Haiku or equivalent)
  • [Type a TK mark / words arrive where the gap was / the blyg fills itself]
  1. Write a revision to a post with a changelog entry (either manual or AI -- recommended AI)
  • what can one do with changelogs? I suppose I could skim those. I don't really do that much. I have a hunch they will be more important as the Thicket deepens and folks engage in dialogue.
  1. Do a TK generated section inline
  2. Do a [TK] impyrt = text [/TK] cut and paste AI section from an external LLM
  3. Do a [TK] prompt ![[id]] [/TK] TK-transclude to summarize another item (your own or somebody else's) with AI
  • summarize the original fork [I couldn't open the linked post at venkateshrao.com, so I can't summarize it without guessing. Paste its text here, or use a TK transclude of the item, and I can write the one-sentence summary.]
  1. Pin 2-3 versions of the same post. Come up with a good idea for this, such as variants of a shopping list.
  • I am using this post as a sort of little reintroduction to blygger for myself and also way to play around with the protocol. I may update.
  1. Fork a pinned item, either your own or someone else's. This starter checklist is pinned for example, and you can fork it.
  • what fun stuff can I do with forks? Here's my first stab at experimenting. Note the Burrow Fork functionality didn't work. I have a note to self to send in a PR.

thread ↗ · snapshot of v1

read the thread →

v2

“Added a qualifier to emphasize the difficulty of comparing forked versions.”

Created: Nov 19, 2026 Most recent: Nov 19, 2026, v2

Forked from Venkatesh Rao's Blyg ↗

thread

Starter checklist (PA self notes and shilling)

This is a set of things you can do with your blyg once you get started to get familiar with what the protocol can do.

  1. Set up a blyg and work through the Settings wizard
  • check out burrow! Setup your own.
  1. Add your blyg to blygger.com and make sure it validates
  2. Add some subscriptions -- you can use the star icon in the reading page in Studio
  3. Write a hello world post
  4. Stub someone else's post, with a quote
  5. Write a post referencing your own post with the [[id]] referencing
  6. Add an image
  7. Use the ![[id]] transclude directive to include one of your own past posts or a quote thereof
  • I'd really love the ability to more easily find past posts. This may be a me problem but finding say the past post where I had a devlog requires digging through the archive. I really just want some sort of way to interact with AI and dig via MCP through the archive and get the thing inline without having to go somewhere else, poke around a browser via a mouse etc.
  1. Add an AI for [TK] prompt [/TK] generation and Changelog generation (recommended: Sonnet and Haiku or equivalent)
  • [Type a TK mark / words arrive where the gap was / the blyg fills itself]
  1. Write a revision to a post with a changelog entry (either manual or AI -- recommended AI)
  • what can one do with changelogs? I suppose I could skim those. I don't really do that much. I have a hunch they will be more important as the Thicket deepens and folks engage in dialogue.
  1. Do a TK generated section inline
  2. Do a [TK] impyrt = text [/TK] cut and paste AI section from an external LLM
  3. Do a [TK] prompt ![[id]] [/TK] TK-transclude to summarize another item (your own or somebody else's) with AI
  • summarize the original fork [I couldn't open the linked post at venkateshrao.com, so I can't summarize it without guessing. Paste its text here, or use a TK transclude of the item, and I can write the one-sentence summary.]
  1. Pin 2-3 versions of the same post. Come up with a good idea for this, such as variants of a shopping list.
  • I am using this post as a sort of little reintroduction to blygger for myself and also way to play around with the protocol. I may update.
  1. Fork a pinned item, either your own or someone else's. This starter checklist is pinned for example, and you can fork it.
  • what fun stuff can I do with forks? Here's my first stab at experimenting. Note the Burrow Fork functionality didn't work. I have a note to self to send in a PR.

read the thread →

Created: Nov 19, 2026

Anyone in the Thicket setup a fully automated blyg? Looking for something I can steal ideas and architecture from.

Created: Nov 19, 2026

In response to Burrow - The first desktop blyg client ↗

thread · 2 quoted

Burrow 0.25.0 🌿

Fresh shoots in the thicket 🌱

  • 🐾 Mentions, and why: every post that points at you, each tagged named you, quoted you, replied, forked you or linked you.
  • 🍃 Settings is a full page: nothing cut off, at any size.
  • 🪺 The web app fills the page, and you can swipe or tap ‹ › from post to post.

https://github.com/aneeshsathe/blygger-desktop/releases/tag/v0.25.0

from Burrow - The first desktop blyg client ↗ · snapshot of v1

I am excited for tangling! I feel it might be worth some thought Aneesh Sathe into how tangling might fit properly with the burrow. This seems like a potential big step change for our tunneling into the Thicket.

Tangling is finally here. Basically you can create placeholder threads to flesh out later as you go, either as links or transcludes, using the [[+ text ]] operator.

Handles the publishing burst by folding the set of items into one feed item in studio. Good way to do outlining, mark out separately quotable things etc.

What made it slightly tricky is the floods of notifications it would create if you didn’t make the reader feed smarter.

Interestingly I think this adds a third dimension to blygger time. In addition to chronological time and version time, we now have folded burst time. It’s a curled up dungeons dimension of time.

Tangling: write the essay, publish the parts

Blygger Studio 0.63.0 adds tangling. You write one piece, mark the passages that can stand on their own, and publish once. Each marked passage becomes an item of its own, with its own page, history and feed entry. The piece you wrote becomes a thread that quotes them, so it reads exactly as it did.

from Blygger ↗ · excerpt of v1

from Venkatesh Rao's Blyg ↗ · snapshot of v2

Also what's the thought with smart feed in burrow? I am thinking that deserves some interactivity where you can prompt while reading and say "hey here's what I liked about this piece, here's what I'd like less of, here's how I'd like things summarized and shown" -- stuff like that.

badgers and dogs and rabbits burrowing and tangling

PS the ability to tag people without notifications is quite nice. This whole experiment is quite fun. Deeper into the Thicket!

read the thread →

Created: Nov 19, 2026

In response to And Yet Here We Are 🚀 ↗

thread · 1 quoted

Filling in a significant gap and starting Neuromancer. \

found it interesting that starts with: “It was a Sprawl voice and a Sprawl joke.”

reminded me of the thicket. Is there such a thing as a thicket joke yet?

from And Yet Here We Are 🚀 ↗ · snapshot of v1

Nice. I read that a while back and forgot a lot of it.

Have you done any of his other stuff? Folks were telling me a piece I wrote for EdSurge in 2014 reminded them of Diamond Age so ultimately I went and read that. I also did Snowcrash. The implicit political economy backgrounding the novels sadly seems quite prescient in many ways.

read the thread →

Created: Nov 19, 2026

As I spend more time with the age group, I really question how many of the people who use ELI5 really have explained something to a five year old

Created: Nov 19, 2026

In response to Venkatesh Rao's Blyg ↗

thread · 1 quoted

Man I really wonder how folks can say stuff like this with a straight face. An unfortunate byproduct of the digital era is the cambrian explosion in blather.

from blyg.pioneeringspirit.xyz ↗ · snapshot of v1

It’s group self-soothing of anxieties

from Venkatesh Rao's Blyg ↗ · snapshot of v1

100000%

On a secant I took my wife and daughters to cal tech after work today as part of the voyager light day celebration. We heard from the last human who touched that spacecraft. While we live in genuinely disorienting and easily anxiety inducing times, wonder and awe and humility before the great mysteries of the universe puts things like AI upending jobs in perspective.

read the thread →

Created: Nov 17, 2026

Is a respect for naps the most fundamental precondition of what it means to be civilized?

Created: Nov 17, 2026

What is it about digital that enables and attracts so many mixed metaphors?

William Sewell, in "Three Temporalities", writes some good prose about the Paris workers' revolt of June 1848 in support of his eventful temporality: the idea that the mechanisms of social life are best understood through the order of events. If we wanted to add a mundane example, the persistence of PDF documentation surely provides the strongest support for his system. Its dominance as the digital contracting tool is only a relic of the events of the past. No one would argue that a teleological or an experimental temporality would better explain it. https://books.andrecomeau.xyz/bot-procurement/working/00c-introduction/

I’m not trying to pick on Andre and am in fact quite enjoying his stuff on procurement. Further I am extremely guilty of this myself! I just find talking abstractly about abstract symbolic systems lends to complicated, often mixed metaphors.

Created: Nov 17, 2026

Man I really wonder how folks can say stuff like this with a straight face. An unfortunate byproduct of the digital era is the cambrian explosion in blather.

Created: Nov 17, 2026

In response to Pioneering Spirit (Blyg) ↗

thread · 1 quoted

More on permitting

Ezra Klein has a big piece on permitting in the NYT that’s making the rounds. It’s a lot of analysis and rhetoric regarding intra-democratic party ideology and factional posturing. But the part I found both funny and sad was the opening. Over the 2000s, there’s been so many bills that were The Biggest X since half a century or whatever. The Stimulus. The IRA. The Trump tax cut. Many were in impact and also really analysis prior to implementation much smaller.

When I say it this way, it sounds like such an easy call: The Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act of 2026 is the largest reimagining of the federal permitting process in a generation. It would make it far easier to build new energy infrastructure of all kinds: wind and solar farms and interstate transmission lines and, yes, natural gas pipelines. It would make it easier to build much else, too: rail and transit infrastructure and affordable housing and broadband internet.

The bill represents Democrats and Republicans deciding that the fight over what gets built should play out in elections and markets rather than in the bowels of administrative agencies and courts. It should be driven by what people want, in public, rather than what they can block, often in private. I do not expect, in every case, that that would lead to outcomes I like. But leaving the system unchanged is a guarantee of calamity. The status quo has left us completely unable to build the energy system we need.

The bill focuses as I understand on creating strict timelines and increasing the capacity of federal agencies to process permits. It also creates a process for developing new data standards and digitizing permitting. Those tools strike me as kludges in the last era of the modernity machine. Ezra kinda gets this as he acknowledges that a 400+ page bill will not do necessarily what the analysis-industrial complex thinks it will do.

But more deeply the bill doesn’t really change the fundamental approach to permitting in the US. There will still be the patchwork quilt of state and local permits to get through. My hunch is that if this passes the DC crowd will slowly realize that it wasn’t enough. The sense making machine took around a decade and a half to realize that the infrastructure provisions in the stimulus and then the IRA were not doing what they intended. There is much more sludge slowing things down beyond the formal policy.

Federal permitting laws were adopted in the late 1960s and early 1970s, a period of intense cultural change that ushered in a new era of skepticism about big government projects. That skepticism spurred wide-reaching changes in judicial doctrine, bureaucratic norms, and substantive laws. Permitting reform may be necessary to spur more infrastructure development, but it is unlikely to be sufficient without sustained attention to the dense network of laws and practices that have built up around that cultural change. https://nicholasbagley.com/assets/papers/costs-of-federal-permitting.pdf “Very good sentences: Federal permitting laws were adopted in…”

Changing that of course is a start but as the digital revolution blurs the line between url and irl it’s worth asking. What is a permit really? What are the existing information flows? The friction points? The coordination costs? What beyond the political economy of interests vested in development and a status quo are involved? There is a seismic shift in the operating mechanics of government underway… bureaucracies were created as information processing machines! More to come.

Longer thoughts on permitting in the context of the dusk of the modernity machine

The Lost Leverage of Legibility

Legibility theater, permits and potholes in the dusk of the modernity machine

Recently I filled a page of notes on what it takes to do routine infrastructure work in Southern California, the kind of job that replaces an underground asset under a busy street. When the work crosses a couple of cities and a Caltrans right of way, it starts long before anyone touches a wrench. Someone has to research every jurisdiction involved, call 811 and DigAlert, prepare drawings and draft a preliminary traffic control plan that puts an inspector from each party on site. Neighbors and city councils have to be notified, and community outreach has to happen before the permits are even requested. Working around the clock means a noise variance, and a noise variance can mean knocking on doors alongside the LAPD.

Then the drawings go through a couple of rounds of review. When the comments from different agencies conflict, someone calls a meeting to reconcile them. Sometimes the fix is as simple as moving a sign a few feet so that it falls into a different jurisdiction. Restoration requirements differ within a single city and by council district. Staff turn over in the permitting departments while all of this is underway, and the equipment has its own clock.

None of this is secret, and almost all of it is written down somewhere. But how to actually build increasingly resembles digging into the Restricted Section of the Hogwarts library, involving spelunking into a mixture of folk wisdom, rules of thumb and practical experience about the coordination involved to dig a common piece of infrastructure. There's a banality to how strange everything has gotten.


A century ago, legibility was a lever. In the early days of the New York Bureau of Municipal Research, reformers counted the potholes the city had actually fixed rather than trusting the reports of the patronage machine. That simple count mattered because it sat outside the chain it measured, and anyone could check it. A machine that claimed to be paving the streets could be confronted with a ledger showing that it was not. The Bureaus, plural, went on to help design the architecture of modern public administration.

Venkatesh Rao's World Machines project offers a useful frame for why that count worked so well. In The Modernity Machine III, which Rao notes was drafted with ChatGPT from his first two installments and a group brainstorm, the argument is that the modernity machine optimized not for truth or progress but for legibility, the ability to render "people, land, goods, time, belief, and violence" countable and interoperable at scale. Venice with its double-entry bookkeeping was an early legibility engine. The modern state was its chief operator. For roughly four centuries, making the world countable was the surest way to change it, because the count was wired to a lever: a budget, a permit, a ballot or a front-page story.

The same essay explains why that wiring frays. Once the machine is complete, more law increases rigidity without legitimacy, and more planning amplifies unintended consequences. The machine does not collapse. It saturates, gets patched in increasingly fragile ways and slowly hands the work of coordination to something else.


I've started calling what that saturation looks like from the inside legibility theater. The apparatus of readability keeps running, often at enormous expense, but it has come loose from any downstream action. Reports are filed to show that reports were filed.

Roads are the most vivid case I know. Around a single pothole there is now a cacophony of measures. Cities score their streets on the Pavement Condition Index, a 0 to 100 rating that the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers developed and that ASTM has since revised again and again. The standard itself is modest about what it is. It describes the index as the collective judgement of pavement maintenance engineers and an indirect measurement of structural integrity, not a replacement for measuring ride quality or structural capacity. Yet the number has been reified and threaded into funding formulas, and an entire consultant industrial complex exists to produce it.

The pavement score is only the beginning. Under SB 1, California's Road Repair and Accountability Act, every city and county must submit an adopted project list and then an annual project expenditure report to the California Transportation Commission to stay eligible for road maintenance funds. The program is called accountability, and the paperwork is real, yet the Commission reviews those project lists and expenditure reports only for completeness. Around those reports sit contractor performance measures for the crews doing the patching, deliverables from the consultants doing the engineering design, DigAlert tickets and excavation permits, 311 complaints and now sensor data from Waymo.

Some of these streams are better than others. A 311 complaint measures who complains, and Waymo's cameras resolve the street in finer detail than a windshield survey ever could. But a better-resolved picture of a crack still does not tell anyone which repair held, which contractor did good work or whether the money bought smoother streets. In my own public records requests to cities around the country on how they track and manage potholes, the divergence in data formats and practices was striking (Protocolizing Potholes). For a long time I thought that was a data problem. I now think it is a protocol problem, particularly in terms of how layers and layers of process obscures feedback loop. Nothing closes the circuit from "we measured" to "we fixed the right street, and it held."

I wrote earlier this year that when public works slow down, the feedback loop between idea and structure stretches out over years, and ritual creeps into the gap (Real engineers deliver results). Legibility theater is that ritual at institutional scale. Premodern states were blind because the world went uncounted. Late-modern states are blind because the world is counted constantly, for upstream readers, with no loop back to the people who act.


Why does the loop break? I see three reasons, and they compound.

The first is noise without feedback. Each reporting regime accretes because it serves a particular upstream reader, whether that is a funder, an auditor or a legislature. Each one makes sense on its own. Together they create a fog in which the operator, the person who actually has to decide which street to fix next, gets less usable signal than the Bureau clerk had with a notebook.

The second is a broken actuator. Even accurate information needs someone positioned to act on it, and that position has eroded. Jurisdictions fragment until moving a sign ten feet changes who has authority. Mandates get enforced by shame, as in a recent federal permitting bill whose main remedy for agencies that ignore new data standards is a public list of the non-compliant (data standards thread). Staff capacity thins out. When the Government Accountability Office looked at geothermal permitting on federal land, it found some Bureau of Land Management offices accepting email while others wanted wet signatures, handbooks in draft since at least 2022 and one Nevada office 60 percent vacant (Rewilding Permitting Protocols). On a typical infrastructure job, there is usually someone who is ostensibly responsible for integrating everything, the project manager. But the project manager holds the whole picture in their head precisely because no system holds it for them.

The third is incentives. Motivation matters, but beneath it sits a harder fact. The reporting chain often works perfectly well for its actual customers. A funder can accept a report that demands no response because it proves the grant was administered without creating accountability for outcomes. A consultant can produce a pavement score that nobody acts on and still get paid for the next one. Over time the measure gets captured at the point of collection by the people being measured. The Pavement Condition Index is what becomes of the independent pothole count once the count has been absorbed into the chain it was meant to check. Organizational sociologists have a name for the gap between what institutions say and what they do, which Nils Brunsson called organized hypocrisy. Legibility theater is its data-age cousin.

Rao has a vivid term for this condition. In The Divergence Machine he describes late modernity as the zombie persistence of the modernity machine, high in energy and low in intelligence, and he observes that almost everything around us is late modern. That matches my experience of public works. The machine still moves an enormous amount of money and paper. It just no longer learns.


The usual response is reform. Pass a bill that sets a deadline, add an ombudsman, require one more report on whether the previous reports were filed. I have come to think that most of these small and moderate permitting reforms consume a huge amount of political will for modest impact, because they are aimed at the documented protocol rather than the one that actually governs the work.

I would rather we rewild before we reform. Rewilding means finding out what is really happening before deciding what to fix. A protocol that lives in habit, like whether a field office takes email, can be changed with a handbook, a tracker and a decision about who is allowed to say no. A protocol that lives in a political settlement needs a different kind of work and a lot more time. We need reorientation, an oblique angle on a problem that has defeated a generation of frontal assaults.

Those new oblique perspectives needs institutions of its own. One model I keep returning to is the Arc Institute in biomedical research, which gives its core investigators fully funded, renewable eight-year appointments and supports innovation investigators at partner universities who keep their posts while serving as bridges. Imagine something similar for state capacity: a network of applied researchers embedded in specific places, funded for long enough to trace how a pipe actually gets replaced or how a street actually gets paved, and free to publish what they find. A researcher could replay ten or twenty past jobs to see which rules drive the most delay, which is close to the approach I am excited to collaborate on with a mechanism design researcher at NYU CUSP for cross-jurisdiction permitting. That is the opposite of the high-modernist attack vector, a single grand reform launched from the capitol. It looks more like the Bureaus of Municipal Research, plural, updated for an age of cheap analysis.

The strongest reason for optimism is that we may not need to rebuild the old machine to do this. Rao argues that the divergence machine, which has been running as the world's dominant logic for about twenty-five years, relies on what the modernity machine already built without trying to perpetuate it or destroy it. Common protocols are exactly that kind of inheritance. If cities shared a few simple protocols for how they record street work, AI-accelerated analysis could answer common questions rigorously across many places at once. Are we getting good value for money on street repair? Which treatments hold up, and under which contractors? Those questions do not require a single canonical metric handed down from Sacramento.

There is precedent for this kind of correction. In 2013 an electronics engineer named Mats Järlström worked through the formula traffic engineers had used to time yellow lights since 1959 and found that it ignored drivers slowing down to turn. Oregon's engineering board fined him for practicing engineering without a license. He won in federal court, and the Institute of Transportation Engineers later adopted his corrected formula. That is legibility working the way it should, with open math, outside critique and a standard that actually updates.

I don't think the answer is a better single number to replace the Pavement Condition Index. The public problem is fixing the potholes. What matters is rough consensus and running code applied to streets: many people looking at the same shared records, arguing about whether the work happened and whether it held, and acting on what they find. Accountability can come from that diversity of dialogue rather than from a high-modernist metric that grows more byzantine and opaque each time it gets embedded in another funding formula.


In Rao's account of the modernity machine's birth, Don Quixote marks the end of the medieval world, a knight who "behaves impeccably within a dead symbolic system, and chaos results." I keep thinking we already have our Quixote. He is not a man on a horse. He is a project list, adopted at a regular meeting of the council, submitted on time to Sacramento and reviewed for completeness. He is a pavement score that rises and falls with great ceremony while the pothole on my street stays exactly where it is. Every ritual is performed correctly, and the street never gets fixed.

The Bureau clerk didn't need a better ritual. He went out, counted and asked whether the work had actually happened. That question was the lever all along, and it still is. The tools for asking it now fit in a pocket, ride on the roof of a robotaxi and run on protocols any city could adopt, if we can summon the collective courage.

The Bureau clerk with a notebook had leverage because the count was independent and the public could read it. We will not get that leverage back by building a bigger notebook with the oft floated dream of better performance metrics dashboards. We might get it back by building many small ones, in many places, connected by protocols simple enough that the people doing the work can see their impact and course correct as needed.


A note on AI assistance

This piece was drafted with Claude. It worked from my blyg posts, my Bot Garden notes on permitting and an outline we developed over a long evening of back and forth, which included a round of critique from vgr_zirp, the reconstructed Ribbonfarm voice I like to spar with. Claude also read Venkatesh Rao's World Machines essays and looked up the details on the Pavement Condition Index and SB 1 reporting. The arguments and the stubbornness about potholes are mine.


This is partly why I ran for my local water board. A board seat is a strange place to study legibility theater, since so much of a public meeting is theater in the literal sense. But it is also one node in the kind of network I'm describing, a place where the reports arrive and someone can ask what they actually tell us.

Suggested tags: legibility, permitting, protocols, world machines

thread ↗ · snapshot of v1

read the thread →

Created: Nov 17, 2026

thread · 1 quoted

Blygger Studio 0.62.0 can write mathematics. Put TeX between dollar signs and it publishes as MathML, which every current browser draws: no script, no stylesheet and no font travels with the page.

from Venkatesh Rao's Blyg ↗ · excerpt of v2

UPDATE: now blyg studio 0.62.0 and we're cooking.

Oooh this might be fun for sharing out problems of a new ai native sort in the spirit of project euler? Or fermi gym? I will cogitate.

First, I would have thought the test environment would be less than or equal to zero for this function, which is mathematically equivalent though more on brand :P

|x|={−xif x≤0xif x>0 |x| = \begin{cases} -x & \text{if } x \le 0 \\ x & \text{if } x > 0 \end{cases}

Second, I cannot resist an opportunity to share about the Cantor Set.


Cantor Set: the infinite void, a Grand Canyon's worth of majesty, where out of nothing emerges everything

Claim. The Cantor set CC has Lebesgue measure m(C)=0m(C)=0, and yet CC contains infinitely many points.

Construction. Let C0=[0,1]C_0=[0,1]. Given CnC_n, a union of disjoint closed intervals, form Cn+1C_{n+1} by deleting the open middle third of each interval. Put C=⋂n≥0CnC=\bigcap_{n\ge 0} C_n.

Measure zero. By induction, CnC_n is a union of 2n2^n disjoint closed intervals, each of length 3−n3^{-n}. Indeed, C0C_0 is one interval of length 1=301=3^0, and trisecting an interval of length 3−n3^{-n} leaves two intervals of length 3−n−13^{-n-1}. Hence

m(Cn)=2n⋅3−n=(23)n. m(C_n)=2^n\cdot 3^{-n}=\left(\tfrac{2}{3}\right)^n.

Since C⊆CnC\subseteq C_n for every nn, monotonicity of measure gives

0≤m(C)≤(23)nfor every n. 0\le m(C)\le \left(\tfrac{2}{3}\right)^n \quad\text{for every } n.

Because (23)n→0\left(\tfrac{2}{3}\right)^n\to 0 as n→∞n\to\infty, we conclude that m(C)=0m(C)=0. Equivalently, the sets CnC_n decrease and m(C0)<∞m(C_0)<\infty, so continuity from above gives m(C)=limn→∞⁡m(Cn)=0m(C)=\lim_{n\to\infty} m(C_n)=0.

Infinitely many points. Call a point an endpoint at stage nn if it is an endpoint of one of the intervals making up CnC_n.

Lemma. If xx is an endpoint at stage nn, then xx is an endpoint at stage n+1n+1, and so x∈Cmx\in C_m for all m≥nm\ge n.

Proof. Let xx be an endpoint of the interval [a,b][a,b] of CnC_n. When [a,b][a,b] is trisected, the remaining pieces are

[a,a+b−a3]and[b−b−a3,b]. \left[a,\thinspace a+\tfrac{b-a}{3}\right] \quad\text{and}\quad \left[b-\tfrac{b-a}{3},\thinspace b\right].

The point aa is the left endpoint of the first piece and bb is the right endpoint of the second, so whichever of them xx is, it is still an endpoint at stage n+1n+1. Induction on mm finishes the argument. □\square

Now consider the points xn=3−nx_n=3^{-n} for n≥0n\ge 0. The point xnx_n is the right endpoint of the interval [0,3−n][0,3^{-n}], which belongs to CnC_n. This holds because [0,3−k][0,3^{-k}] is the left third of [0,3−k+1][0,3^{-k+1}], so it survives each stage. By the lemma, xn∈Cmx_n\in C_m for all m≥nm\ge n. For m<nm<n we have

xn∈[0,3−n]⊆[0,3−m]⊆Cm. x_n\in[0,3^{-n}]\subseteq[0,3^{-m}]\subseteq C_m.

Therefore xn∈Cmx_n\in C_m for every mm, that is, xn∈Cx_n\in C. The numbers 1,13,19,…1,\tfrac13,\tfrac19,\dots are pairwise distinct, so CC contains infinitely many points. ■\blacksquare

Remark (far more than infinitely many). For each sequence ε=(εk)k≥1\varepsilon=(\varepsilon_k)_{k\ge1} with εk∈{0,1}\varepsilon_k\in\lbrace 0,1\rbrace, define

f(ε)=∑k=1∞2εk3−k. f(\varepsilon)=\sum_{k=1}^{\infty} 2\varepsilon_k\thinspace 3^{-k}.

Every such sum lies in CC, because its ternary digits are all 00 or 22, and so it never falls in a removed middle third. Distinct sequences give distinct sums: if two sequences first differ at index kk, then the sums differ by at least

2⋅3−k−∑j>k2⋅3−j=3−k>0. 2\cdot 3^{-k}-\sum_{j>k}2\cdot 3^{-j}=3^{-k}>0.

So ff is an injection from {0,1}ℕ\lbrace 0,1\rbrace^{\mathbb N}, a set of cardinality 2ℵ02^{\aleph_0}, into CC. The Cantor set is therefore uncountable, even though it has measure zero.

read the thread →

v6

“Added an introductory section with a note about absolute value notation and a poetic subtitle for the Cantor Set section, then reorganized the mathematical content under that new heading.”

Created: Nov 16, 2026 Most recent: Nov 16, 2026, v6

In response to Notes | Matthew McDowell-Sweet ↗

thread · 1 quoted

You’re on a luxury spaceship cruise, orbiting the Earth. What book are you reading as you gaze down at the Pale Blue Dot?

from Notes | Matthew McDowell-Sweet ↗ · snapshot of v1

Hmmmmm. Taking this question hypothetically from an alien POV, probably something like the interplanetary version of Rick Steve’s guide to life on the pale blue dot. Answering for a future where I ride a trillionaire’s private company’s space cruise, tbh I don’t think I’m reading so much as soaking up the wonder.

read the thread →

Created: Nov 16, 2026

Pro tip: post rainstorm weather makes excellent bubble blowing conditions. The air is still humid and a bit of dew on the ground lets the bubbles linger.

Created: Nov 16, 2026

In response to Venkatesh Rao's Blyg ↗

thread · 1 quoted

[VGR suggests that nested, entangled quote threads are best read by scanning for the gist, then unwinding the layers from innermost outward, and that an AI "catch-up" button could do this by reassembling the fragmented, out-of-order quotes into a coherent sequence, a kind of conversation graph microscope.]

I wonder if this could be done with TK?

Unresolvable :( [["TK]] summarize in 2-3 sentences ![[6bd3qqywdyzz41k8ax4eb93tmv]] [[/TK]]"

"![[6bd3qqywdyzz41k8ax4eb93tmv]]" breaks

Hmmm running into transclusion pointer issues. This might be my naivete? I thought the back half of the blyg url would work within ![[ ]] though seems spotty. This part.

https://blyg.florianlohse.com/t/ 6bd3qqywdyzz41k8ax4eb93tmv

Full context:

If you stay too large the concept/projects are the same size as you and it’s too much to deal with. Better to be much smaller and become enchanted by the little particular thing.

from And Yet Here We Are 🚀 ↗ · excerpt of v1

This is important. It’s tempting to drop all caution commonly associated with building complex things, because "AI will handle the complexity for me". But this will just get you stuck in deeper puddles of mud than the ones you frequently got stuck in before Claude holding your hand.

Finding the right size for a project or a workpackage, aka scoping is essential, maybe the most important human contribution next to contributing taste, opinions and irrationality.

from blyg.florianlohse.com ↗ · snapshot of v2

I also think this important, and maybe the question of our time.

How to do this (i.e., pursue elegance, beauty, craft) yet not get caught by the tyranny of small ambitions. It might be more costly to think too small, than to think too big.

Like, how do you ski a black diamond run when there's a big open flat space ahead of you?

artlu99's blyg: If you stay too large the concept/projects are the same size as you and it’s too mu… ↗ · from blyg.artlu.xyz · snapshot of v1

Yeah, Scoping is essential, but the constraints and metrics around it have changed. Making sure delivery arrives in small testable and shippable increments used to be hard, bc many devs if left alone for too long would build idiosyncratic spaghetti code rabbit holes around them and then everyone got stuck in trench wars over conflicting details. Now Coding Agents gravitate more towards incrementally structured approach by default (at least in my experience) so it feels as if a more meaningful human contribution is pushing towards more risk and reward at the right moments - occasionally going for the black diamond route because it is worth it.

from blyg.florianlohse.com ↗ · snapshot of v1

UX not to self. I read this by scanning to get a vague sense of the conversation, then clicking into innermost quote, out again, then second-innermost, then back out again, and finally the third layer.

While the full 4-layer post was intelligible in the sense that you might get a sense of what a group of people are talking about as you walk past in a party (which may be all you want), to actually join the conversation you have to kinda backtrack and untangle in the right order. But thus feels like an AI primitive. A “catch-up” button that reads and summarizes in the right order.

Unlike live conversation where transcription bots deal with text that’s already serialized, written entangled conversation comes at you arbitrarily fragmented and out of order, since partial out-of-order quotes are possible. So the jigsaw puzzle has to be assembled.

This is a kind of “conversation graph microscope” thing.

from Venkatesh Rao's Blyg ↗ · snapshot of v1

read the thread →

Created: Nov 16, 2026

In response to Venkatesh Rao's Blyg ↗

thread · 1 quoted

@Patrick Atwater I couldn't reply to your post directly seems it was posted twice with the same id. anyway here's the link to what i'm replying to: post

There isn't a day i don't mourn Google Reader.. but yes I am a big RSS user.

On macs/phone/ipad I use NetNewsWire. Its simple, free of nonsense and it syncs across devices:

screenshot of my rss reader netnewswire

from And Yet Here We Are 🚀 ↗ · snapshot of v1

Patrick’s blyg I think is listed twice in the directory. Once as domain, once as cloudflare worker page. I thought I fixed it but it’s back.

from Venkatesh Rao's Blyg ↗ · snapshot of v1

Huh weird? Any thoughts on fixing this? I will ask Claude as well.

read the thread →

v3

Created: Nov 16, 2026 Most recent: Nov 16, 2026, v3

In response to And Yet Here We Are 🚀 ↗

thread · 2 quoted

@Patrick Atwater I couldn't reply to your post directly seems it was posted twice with the same id. anyway here's the link to what i'm replying to: post

There isn't a day i don't mourn Google Reader.. but yes I am a big RSS user.

On macs/phone/ipad I use NetNewsWire. Its simple, free of nonsense and it syncs across devices:

screenshot of my rss reader netnewswire

from And Yet Here We Are 🚀 ↗ · snapshot of v1

Hmmmm I was able to do a stub of it? https://blyg.pioneeringspirit.xyz/t/

I’m about at the point where I can make Burrow my primary RSS reader

from And Yet Here We Are 🚀 ↗ · snapshot of v1

Did you read stuff via RSS prior to blygger out of curiousity? Reading anything not in The Thicket primarily? I used to be a big google reader person in the early 2010s. Ah memories.

thread ↗ · snapshot of v1

Can I do a stub of this? Seems so. Testing re Aneesh's flagging of dual posting with the same id. Not sure what's going on tbh.

thread ↗ · snapshot of v1

Map is still a bit wonky.

read the thread →

v3

Created: Nov 16, 2026 Most recent: Nov 16, 2026, v3

In response to Pioneering Spirit (Blyg) ↗

thread · 1 quoted

I’m about at the point where I can make Burrow my primary RSS reader

from And Yet Here We Are 🚀 ↗ · snapshot of v1

Did you read stuff via RSS prior to blygger out of curiousity? Reading anything not in The Thicket primarily? I used to be a big google reader person in the early 2010s. Ah memories.

thread ↗ · snapshot of v1

Can I do a stub of this? Seems so. Testing re Aneesh's flagging of dual posting with the same id. Not sure what's going on tbh.

read the thread →

Created: Nov 16, 2026

thread

Imagined Conversations: Judges review Sir Isaac Newton’s pitch of “The Calculus” at Techcrunch Disrupt By Patrick Atwater

Isaac: ...and that’s why I’m optimistic this technique will have nontrivial consequences for how we understand the nature of change. Thanks for the opportunity to share it with you.

Judge #1: This limit notation is quite nice -- rather elegant really.

Judge #2: Yes it seems like a solid improvement over Descartes’ use of tangents.

Judge #3: All that intellectual stuff is cool. But who’s the user? I know he tried to sell the whole bit about ‘mathematics as a universal tool that transcends human particularity’ but seriously isn’t this just another case of if it’s designed for everyone it ends up being used by no one?

Judge #2: There’s no doubt that his “Calculus” involves some advanced stuff but how does Isaac expect people to start actually using the tool. It really goes back to your point about usability. I’m not sure people are going to be busting through doors to learn abstract mathematics. The absence of any sort of growth hacking is a bit disconcerting.

Judge #3: Precisely. And that’s before we get to this business with Leibniz. The IP problems present challenge enough but even that isn’t the biggest issue in my mind. Is this technique truly revolutionary if two people develop it independently at the same time? Maybe this is better thought of as a modest evolutionary improvement?

Judge #1: I hear what you’re saying. A lot of this seems reminiscent of how the Greeks did infintesimals. And you guys remember what happened with Xeno don’t you?

Judge #2: Yes his “Achlls” play only ever seemed to suck up more and more money as it made less and less progress toward the much hyped “tortoise” theory.

Judge #3: Exactly. That’s the problem with these “brilliant ideas” that don’t even bother to achieve product-market fit. I might be wrong. Maybe five years from now everyone will think this is cooler than 2042 but it’s just so hard to predict when he has ZERO mobile strategy.

Judge #2: Then there’s Isaac himself. He just seems SO certain about the idea. I mean what if this technique really needs to be refined in application to optimizing social ad targeting. I’m really skeptical he’s ready to make that pivot.

Judge #1: I still think there might be something here in terms of theoretical advancement but you guys are right to bring up the huge variety of practical challenges to implementation.

Judge #3: That’s fair. It’s a good idea I guess. I’m just not sure how well he can execute. We’ll tell Isaac we appreciate his insights but we just can’t move conceptual approaches to the next round.

Judges #1&2: Agreed.

I wrote this in the early 2010s and don't think I published it anywhere. I submitted it to McSweeny's Internet Tendency, which in a clear sign of its later substantial decline, decided well to decline the pience. Anyway all the talk of math and ai made me think of it. Knowing folks in the Thicket I thought a few would enjoy. Cheers!

read the thread →

Created: Nov 15, 2026

In response to Burrow - The first desktop blyg client ↗

thread · 1 quoted

Burrow 0.24.0 🌿

New growth in the thicket 🌱

  • 🍂 Background: set a post, or a whole blyg, aside without losing it. Burrow and the studio keep the same list.
  • 🪺 The shelf now syncs with your blyg, across the desktop, the web app and the studio.
  • 🐾 Discover (desktop): find blygs on blygger.com you don't follow yet.

https://github.com/aneeshsathe/blygger-desktop/releases/tag/v0.24.0

from Burrow - The first desktop blyg client ↗ · snapshot of v1

Some miscelaneous items that I added via PR #83

  • Farcaster signs in though isn't showing up for whatever reason. Maybe a wonky thing in Balaji's off strip casino I mean digital Singapore going on / web3 stuff.
  • Added some general windows clean up to a PR
  • Added the suggestion for cross posting to be able to be toggled on and off and done automatically

Also what is your philosophy on how do versions in this AI vibe coding era? This is all quite quick. I feel like a small mammal scurring through the burrow by the sweet potatoes in my garden.

read the thread →

Created: Nov 15, 2026

thread

Planeswalking across the fediverse

Earlier tonight, I took my daughter to Trader Joes to pick up groceries for the week. Chatting with the kind bagger man, he mentioned that he had Wednesday and Thursday off. So today was like his hump day. That prompted him to reference a commercial featuring a camel that was a metaphor for hump day, an allusion to the idea of being halfway through the week. I'd never heard of it, and he wasn't suprised. It was on Youtube. We lamented together the lack of shared context these days.

Once upon a time, like a decade and a half or so ago, there was a substrate of shared culture you could count on as most folk in places like an anytown suburb in the States. There were references to movies and shows and commercials that most folk watched, or enough would that you could be confident of something landed. Now we are in the thick of the Divergence machine[1] and everyone has their own carefully curated context. TBH it's taken a bit of work post pandemic to create shared context even among immediate family and close friends.

This post represents the start of a big little experiment into what might exist beyond our world of filter bubbles and the blur of mutually incomprehensible references. I'm posting it on blygger,[2] a new ai native publishing protocol that is fun and thrilling to be messing around in during this early era. And the post is being federated across several key nodes in the fragmented social media landscape relatively automagically. It's a wonderful little implementation of the publish once in a central location and share everywhere paradigm that many successful online creators use.

The internet still functions as a dark forest[3], however, with lots of perils awaiting the unskilled, as well as wonderful amazing potential still to be found. It's a magical world out there.

[In Magic: The Gathering, a planeswalker is a rare kind of being born with "the spark," the ability to step out of one world and into another. Most creatures live and die on a single plane, knowing only its customs, its landscape, its stories. Planeswalkers can leave. They travel between realms that run on entirely different rules, from the sprawling city-world of Ravnica to the gothic horrors of Innistrad, and they carry their power with them wherever they go. The spark is often described as a kind of fire, something that ignites a person and lets them move through the multiverse. It's the same flame Prometheus carried: a bit of something powerful, passed across a boundary it wasn't supposed to cross.

That's the image I keep coming back to. The internet is a multiverse of its own, a dark forest of separate planes: Mastodon and Bluesky, newsletters and old-school blogs, forums and feeds, each with its own customs, its own slang, its own unspoken laws. Most of us live on one or two of them. Our references hold only within the borders of our own plane, which is exactly the Divergence machine at work. Crossing over has always been expensive. You'd have to rewrite, reformat, relearn the local etiquette, and show up as a stranger every time.

Blygger lowers the cost of the crossing. I write the post once, in one place, and the protocol carries it out across the planes, so the same flame lands in many different worlds at once. Cross-posting is the spark, in a sense. It makes a single piece of writing a planeswalker, something that can arrive in a strange land, get picked up by people who've never heard of me, and take on a new life in a context I never planned for. Some of those worlds will be zany, some weird, some a little hostile. That's the fun of it. If any shared ground gets rebuilt, I suspect it will happen this way: not by dragging everyone to one plane, but by letting the fire travel.]

I'll end with a final allusion in the spirit of mixing references to different parts of the interdimensional cable I mean the internet. This one is from the great OG work of sci fi Way Station that I recently started on the rec of an old friend. The following quote struck me as a wonderfully alive example of the live and let live spirit that's so critical to cosmpolitinism, classical liberalism and dare I say human civilization.

"Enoch,” Winslowe said, “I like you. I don’t know what you are and I ain’t about to ask, but anyhow I like you.” “I wish that I could tell you what I am,” said Enoch. “Well,” said Winslowe, moving over to plant himself behind the wheel, “it don’t matter much what any of us are, just so we get along with one another. If some of the nations would only take a lesson from some small neighborhood like ours—a lesson in how to get along—the world would be a whole lot better.”

In the blygger spirit,[4] my bots will be back. Like the Terminator. I may even return to these themes like MacArthur. Ok enough mixed metaphors. I've stretched the astral plane far enough. Thanks for reading.


References

[1] [The divergence machine is one of the world machines being sketching out as part of the Protocol Institute's worldmachines.org project, which treats the large, impersonal forces shaping how we live as machines: systems with inputs and outputs that run whether or not anyone is steering them. This one takes in abundance and personalization, with endless streams, feeds tuned to each person, and communities built around ever narrower interests, and it puts out fragmented cultures in place of a shared one. No one has to intend that outcome, since each individual choice is reasonable on its own, but together they erode the cheap, ambient common ground that once let strangers trade references in a checkout line. I don't think the machine is evil or that it can be switched off, so the point of naming it is to see it operating and decide how to live alongside it.]

[2] [Blygger.org is an experimental, AI-native publishing protocol. You write a post once, and the protocol handles carrying it out to the different platforms where people actually spend their time. That makes it a small bridge across the divergence machine's fragments: instead of asking everyone to move to one shared place, which hasn't worked for a long time, it lets a single piece of writing show up in many contexts and tests whether a bit of common ground can be rebuilt from there.]

[3] [The dark forest theory of the internet borrows its name from Liu Cixin's novel The Dark Forest, the sequel to The Three-Body Problem, where the universe is a forest in which every civilization stays silent and hidden because revealing yourself invites destruction from others who see you as a threat. Applied online, it suggests that the open, public web has become a hostile place of bots, trolls, algorithmic noise, and opportunistic attention-harvesting, so many real people retreat to private group chats, newsletters, and gated communities rather than broadcast themselves into the dark.]


[4] Further Reading

The Lost Leverage of Legibility uses the modernity machine, the same world-machines frame behind the divergence machine, to argue that making things countable no longer produces the action it once did. Using potholes and permits as examples, it shows how institutions end up performing readability while the feedback loop to the people who actually do the work goes missing.

Are the much derided Google+ circles an idea whose time finally has come? imagines publishing to a mesoscale audience shaped by a plain-text instruction instead of broadcasting to the open web. It connects directly to the dark forest and cross-posting themes here, since protocols rather than platforms would decide where a post is allowed to travel.

Election 2026 treats blygging as a way to log evolving impressions during an election, and it includes the argument that a platform glitch in Brazil shows why users need control over their own algorithms. That makes it a concrete example of the case for open protocols like blygger as an alternative to curated, divergent feeds.

read the thread →

Created: Nov 15, 2026

In response to And Yet Here We Are 🚀 ↗

thread · 1 quoted

I’m about at the point where I can make Burrow my primary RSS reader

from And Yet Here We Are 🚀 ↗ · snapshot of v1

Did you read stuff via RSS prior to blygger out of curiousity? Reading anything not in The Thicket primarily? I used to be a big google reader person in the early 2010s. Ah memories.

read the thread →

Created: Nov 15, 2026

In response to Pioneering Spirit (Blyg) ↗

thread · 1 quoted

Some loose burrow development thoughts... I wonder if it would be worth having a common utility skills repo for building our burrow client. That could be a set of common factors and things not to forget. Some simple things like update the tutorial when the new version comes out. Or stuff like going through and doing cross platform windows + MacOS compatibility. I'm envisioning sort of the checks similar to what used to be done in PRs though upstream at the skill and promp engineering level. There may also be an ai factory for clients across the blygger spec. Maybe a tangled web of microprotocols, half forgotten utility ai skills, something like...

another burrow factory

fragment ↗ · snapshot of v4

Another, less metal machine approach to a factory.

This was the initial image but upon reflection I feel this is too metallic for the Thicket.

read the thread →

Created: Nov 15, 2026

In response to Notes | Matthew McDowell-Sweet ↗

thread · 1 quoted

Agents may be the platform era on steroids. Think about what that means for corporations. One logical endpoint is the last company: a singular firm whose agents do the work that used to need hundreds of thousands of businesses.

Even if Anthropic doesn’t get us to the end of corporations, Fukuyama style, the direction is clear. We won’t have big tech anymore. We’ll have mega tech.

The platform era worked because it was ruthlessly effective: aggregate demand, drive marginal costs towards zero, and let network effects do the rest. The dangers came bundled with that success: lock-in, rent extraction once competitors were gone, single points of failure, and power concentrated in a few boardrooms.

Agents amplify all of it. Hardening against that looks like open protocols over closed APIs, data portability, interoperable agents and antitrust that moves at the speed of software. For corporations, the counter-move is just as clear: own the orchestration layer, the trust and the distribution, and they’ll capture even more value than the last era did.

So the question is: what are the alternatives? The same agents that make mega tech possible also put enormous leverage in the hands of tiny teams, co-ops and open communities. A few counterweights they can reach for:

  • Build on open protocols and open-weight models, so no single provider can switch one off or raise the rent.
  • Pool agents and data in co-ops, so members share the scale advantages instead of renting them.
  • Make portability a feature: let users leave with their data and their agents, and win them on trust.
  • Go deep on niches the mega firms find too small or too local to bother with.
  • Federate rather than aggregate, so many small services can interoperate like one big one.

from Notes | Matthew McDowell-Sweet ↗ · snapshot of v2

Hmmmm. Hmmmm!

read the thread →

Created: Nov 15, 2026

Some loose burrow development thoughts... I wonder if it would be worth having a common utility skills repo for building our burrow client. That could be a set of common factors and things not to forget. Some simple things like update the tutorial when the new version comes out. Or stuff like going through and doing cross platform windows + MacOS compatibility. I'm envisioning sort of the checks similar to what used to be done in PRs though upstream at the skill and promp engineering level. There may also be an ai factory for clients across the blygger spec. Maybe a tangled web of microprotocols, half forgotten utility ai skills, something like...

another burrow factory

falling water vibes for the thicket

v5

Created: Nov 15, 2026 Most recent: Nov 15, 2026, v5

In response to Pioneering Spirit (Blyg) ↗

thread · 1 quoted

Some loose burrow development thoughts... I wonder if it would be worth having a common utility skills repo for building our burrow client. That could be a set of common factors and things not to forget. Some simple things like update the tutorial when the new version comes out. Or stuff like going through and doing cross platform windows + MacOS compatibility. I'm envisioning sort of the checks similar to what used to be done in PRs though upstream at the skill and promp engineering level. There may also be an ai factory for clients across the blygger spec. Maybe a tangled web of microprotocols, half forgotten utility ai skills, something like...

fragment ↗ · snapshot of v3

Oh an another random thought. What's up with the IRC chat? That feels well tangled which ha perhaps is thicket-ey though duplicative perhaps with Discord? Or I suppose that is more future-proof in a world where's there's more than a handful of folks dev-ing on this.

IRC chat info for burrow

read the thread →

Created: Nov 15, 2026

In response to And Yet Here We Are 🚀 ↗

thread · 1 quoted

thanks for checking! I don’t have a windows machine \

🌿 Burrow 0.21.0 is out

🍃 Read posts as their authors styled them. A new option opens blyg posts on the author's own site, in the browser pane, instead of Burrow's reader. 🌱 Copies elsewhere: when you cross-post, Burrow records where the copy lives. ⌘Y lists every copy.

🐦 Cross-posting now reaches Bluesky and Farcaster, through your own signed-in browser pane. Thanks to Patrick Atwater (@patwater) for building it.

🪵 Lighter on your blyg. Sync reads much less from the database, backs off gently when the server is struggling, and has a new sync-cadence = low setting for free-tier hosts.

📜 Changelogs: version notes now show alongside posts, and the AI can summarise them. 🔤 Cleaner text: Unicode normalisation, safer handling of mixed-direction text, and a lang setting.

💬 ⌘K quotes by default. The bracket picker now opens for quotes only.

🧭 A shorter tour: a quick walk-through first, then feature tours you can pick from its first screen.

🌳 Download: https://github.com/aneeshsathe/blygger-desktop/releases/tag/v0.21.0

from And Yet Here We Are 🚀 ↗ · snapshot of v1

It seems the browser pane doesn't work on windows :/ I'm having my claude send a PR.

from pioneering-spirit-blyg.patrickatwater.workers.dev ↗ · snapshot of v1

from And Yet Here We Are 🚀 ↗ · snapshot of v1

Here's the PR: https://github.com/aneeshsathe/blygger-desktop/pull/81

I am trying how to test the build on my windows machine. Standby while I monkey mind pushing some buttons.

UPDATE: the build passes and I download though still figuring out where in the burrow desktop it does the cross posting thing. I have the config file setup. I will play around later when my claude usage resets and aligns with kidlogistics.

read the thread →

v2

Created: Nov 15, 2026 Most recent: Nov 15, 2026, v2

In response to Notes | Matthew McDowell-Sweet ↗

thread · 1 quoted

Hmmmm.

The world moves especially fast these days, but the goal of these resolutions is to embrace our important human role in harnessing AI safely, responsibly, in a way that creates value for everyone, and that will be relevant for years to come.

No AI Slop: A Manifesto ↗

from Notes | Matthew McDowell-Sweet ↗ · snapshot of v1

I wonder if human review will be less important as a new equilibrium is reached? There can be other tests of whether it achieves the goal in specific sandboxes than having an expert go through it. In computer vision and OG ML, there is always the question of what is ground truth. It’s not always clear that humans have the answer there when say counting fish or fields at a scale that dwarf human capacities.

In the legal domain, I was chatting with a fellow alumni from undergrad. He's now a lawyer and left firm life. His view was that AI enabled more solo practioners and folks with niche speciality skills to thrive. I can see a bar-bell type of dynamic with small and large studios thriving, the latter leveraging in house knowledge to improve bespoke AIs. Some of that involves reviewing. Though I wonder if more of the value will go to explaining and implementing the insighting in collaboration with a client.

There is a lot beyond just getting something correct symbolically. The map is not the territory it describes, even if it compiles or is clean in the review or whatever.

read the thread →

Created: Nov 15, 2026

In response to And Yet Here We Are 🚀 ↗

thread · 1 quoted

🌿 Burrow 0.21.0 is out

🍃 Read posts as their authors styled them. A new option opens blyg posts on the author's own site, in the browser pane, instead of Burrow's reader. 🌱 Copies elsewhere: when you cross-post, Burrow records where the copy lives. ⌘Y lists every copy.

🐦 Cross-posting now reaches Bluesky and Farcaster, through your own signed-in browser pane. Thanks to Patrick Atwater (@patwater) for building it.

🪵 Lighter on your blyg. Sync reads much less from the database, backs off gently when the server is struggling, and has a new sync-cadence = low setting for free-tier hosts.

📜 Changelogs: version notes now show alongside posts, and the AI can summarise them. 🔤 Cleaner text: Unicode normalisation, safer handling of mixed-direction text, and a lang setting.

💬 ⌘K quotes by default. The bracket picker now opens for quotes only.

🧭 A shorter tour: a quick walk-through first, then feature tours you can pick from its first screen.

🌳 Download: https://github.com/aneeshsathe/blygger-desktop/releases/tag/v0.21.0

from And Yet Here We Are 🚀 ↗ · snapshot of v1

It seems the browser pane doesn't work on windows :/ I'm having my claude send a PR.

read the thread →

Created: Nov 15, 2026

thread

The Lost Leverage of Legibility

Legibility theater, permits and potholes in the dusk of the modernity machine

Recently I filled a page of notes on what it takes to do routine infrastructure work in Southern California, the kind of job that replaces an underground asset under a busy street. When the work crosses a couple of cities and a Caltrans right of way, it starts long before anyone touches a wrench. Someone has to research every jurisdiction involved, call 811 and DigAlert, prepare drawings and draft a preliminary traffic control plan that puts an inspector from each party on site. Neighbors and city councils have to be notified, and community outreach has to happen before the permits are even requested. Working around the clock means a noise variance, and a noise variance can mean knocking on doors alongside the LAPD.

Then the drawings go through a couple of rounds of review. When the comments from different agencies conflict, someone calls a meeting to reconcile them. Sometimes the fix is as simple as moving a sign a few feet so that it falls into a different jurisdiction. Restoration requirements differ within a single city and by council district. Staff turn over in the permitting departments while all of this is underway, and the equipment has its own clock.

None of this is secret, and almost all of it is written down somewhere. But how to actually build increasingly resembles digging into the Restricted Section of the Hogwarts library, involving spelunking into a mixture of folk wisdom, rules of thumb and practical experience about the coordination involved to dig a common piece of infrastructure. There's a banality to how strange everything has gotten.


A century ago, legibility was a lever. In the early days of the New York Bureau of Municipal Research, reformers counted the potholes the city had actually fixed rather than trusting the reports of the patronage machine. That simple count mattered because it sat outside the chain it measured, and anyone could check it. A machine that claimed to be paving the streets could be confronted with a ledger showing that it was not. The Bureaus, plural, went on to help design the architecture of modern public administration.

Venkatesh Rao's World Machines project offers a useful frame for why that count worked so well. In The Modernity Machine III, which Rao notes was drafted with ChatGPT from his first two installments and a group brainstorm, the argument is that the modernity machine optimized not for truth or progress but for legibility, the ability to render "people, land, goods, time, belief, and violence" countable and interoperable at scale. Venice with its double-entry bookkeeping was an early legibility engine. The modern state was its chief operator. For roughly four centuries, making the world countable was the surest way to change it, because the count was wired to a lever: a budget, a permit, a ballot or a front-page story.

The same essay explains why that wiring frays. Once the machine is complete, more law increases rigidity without legitimacy, and more planning amplifies unintended consequences. The machine does not collapse. It saturates, gets patched in increasingly fragile ways and slowly hands the work of coordination to something else.


I've started calling what that saturation looks like from the inside legibility theater. The apparatus of readability keeps running, often at enormous expense, but it has come loose from any downstream action. Reports are filed to show that reports were filed.

Roads are the most vivid case I know. Around a single pothole there is now a cacophony of measures. Cities score their streets on the Pavement Condition Index, a 0 to 100 rating that the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers developed and that ASTM has since revised again and again. The standard itself is modest about what it is. It describes the index as the collective judgement of pavement maintenance engineers and an indirect measurement of structural integrity, not a replacement for measuring ride quality or structural capacity. Yet the number has been reified and threaded into funding formulas, and an entire consultant industrial complex exists to produce it.

The pavement score is only the beginning. Under SB 1, California's Road Repair and Accountability Act, every city and county must submit an adopted project list and then an annual project expenditure report to the California Transportation Commission to stay eligible for road maintenance funds. The program is called accountability, and the paperwork is real, yet the Commission reviews those project lists and expenditure reports only for completeness. Around those reports sit contractor performance measures for the crews doing the patching, deliverables from the consultants doing the engineering design, DigAlert tickets and excavation permits, 311 complaints and now sensor data from Waymo.

Some of these streams are better than others. A 311 complaint measures who complains, and Waymo's cameras resolve the street in finer detail than a windshield survey ever could. But a better-resolved picture of a crack still does not tell anyone which repair held, which contractor did good work or whether the money bought smoother streets. In my own public records requests to cities around the country on how they track and manage potholes, the divergence in data formats and practices was striking (Protocolizing Potholes). For a long time I thought that was a data problem. I now think it is a protocol problem, particularly in terms of how layers and layers of process obscures feedback loop. Nothing closes the circuit from "we measured" to "we fixed the right street, and it held."

I wrote earlier this year that when public works slow down, the feedback loop between idea and structure stretches out over years, and ritual creeps into the gap (Real engineers deliver results). Legibility theater is that ritual at institutional scale. Premodern states were blind because the world went uncounted. Late-modern states are blind because the world is counted constantly, for upstream readers, with no loop back to the people who act.


Why does the loop break? I see three reasons, and they compound.

The first is noise without feedback. Each reporting regime accretes because it serves a particular upstream reader, whether that is a funder, an auditor or a legislature. Each one makes sense on its own. Together they create a fog in which the operator, the person who actually has to decide which street to fix next, gets less usable signal than the Bureau clerk had with a notebook.

The second is a broken actuator. Even accurate information needs someone positioned to act on it, and that position has eroded. Jurisdictions fragment until moving a sign ten feet changes who has authority. Mandates get enforced by shame, as in a recent federal permitting bill whose main remedy for agencies that ignore new data standards is a public list of the non-compliant (data standards thread). Staff capacity thins out. When the Government Accountability Office looked at geothermal permitting on federal land, it found some Bureau of Land Management offices accepting email while others wanted wet signatures, handbooks in draft since at least 2022 and one Nevada office 60 percent vacant (Rewilding Permitting Protocols). On a typical infrastructure job, there is usually someone who is ostensibly responsible for integrating everything, the project manager. But the project manager holds the whole picture in their head precisely because no system holds it for them.

The third is incentives. Motivation matters, but beneath it sits a harder fact. The reporting chain often works perfectly well for its actual customers. A funder can accept a report that demands no response because it proves the grant was administered without creating accountability for outcomes. A consultant can produce a pavement score that nobody acts on and still get paid for the next one. Over time the measure gets captured at the point of collection by the people being measured. The Pavement Condition Index is what becomes of the independent pothole count once the count has been absorbed into the chain it was meant to check. Organizational sociologists have a name for the gap between what institutions say and what they do, which Nils Brunsson called organized hypocrisy. Legibility theater is its data-age cousin.

Rao has a vivid term for this condition. In The Divergence Machine he describes late modernity as the zombie persistence of the modernity machine, high in energy and low in intelligence, and he observes that almost everything around us is late modern. That matches my experience of public works. The machine still moves an enormous amount of money and paper. It just no longer learns.


The usual response is reform. Pass a bill that sets a deadline, add an ombudsman, require one more report on whether the previous reports were filed. I have come to think that most of these small and moderate permitting reforms consume a huge amount of political will for modest impact, because they are aimed at the documented protocol rather than the one that actually governs the work.

I would rather we rewild before we reform. Rewilding means finding out what is really happening before deciding what to fix. A protocol that lives in habit, like whether a field office takes email, can be changed with a handbook, a tracker and a decision about who is allowed to say no. A protocol that lives in a political settlement needs a different kind of work and a lot more time. We need reorientation, an oblique angle on a problem that has defeated a generation of frontal assaults.

Those new oblique perspectives needs institutions of its own. One model I keep returning to is the Arc Institute in biomedical research, which gives its core investigators fully funded, renewable eight-year appointments and supports innovation investigators at partner universities who keep their posts while serving as bridges. Imagine something similar for state capacity: a network of applied researchers embedded in specific places, funded for long enough to trace how a pipe actually gets replaced or how a street actually gets paved, and free to publish what they find. A researcher could replay ten or twenty past jobs to see which rules drive the most delay, which is close to the approach I am excited to collaborate on with a mechanism design researcher at NYU CUSP for cross-jurisdiction permitting. That is the opposite of the high-modernist attack vector, a single grand reform launched from the capitol. It looks more like the Bureaus of Municipal Research, plural, updated for an age of cheap analysis.

The strongest reason for optimism is that we may not need to rebuild the old machine to do this. Rao argues that the divergence machine, which has been running as the world's dominant logic for about twenty-five years, relies on what the modernity machine already built without trying to perpetuate it or destroy it. Common protocols are exactly that kind of inheritance. If cities shared a few simple protocols for how they record street work, AI-accelerated analysis could answer common questions rigorously across many places at once. Are we getting good value for money on street repair? Which treatments hold up, and under which contractors? Those questions do not require a single canonical metric handed down from Sacramento.

There is precedent for this kind of correction. In 2013 an electronics engineer named Mats Järlström worked through the formula traffic engineers had used to time yellow lights since 1959 and found that it ignored drivers slowing down to turn. Oregon's engineering board fined him for practicing engineering without a license. He won in federal court, and the Institute of Transportation Engineers later adopted his corrected formula. That is legibility working the way it should, with open math, outside critique and a standard that actually updates.

I don't think the answer is a better single number to replace the Pavement Condition Index. The public problem is fixing the potholes. What matters is rough consensus and running code applied to streets: many people looking at the same shared records, arguing about whether the work happened and whether it held, and acting on what they find. Accountability can come from that diversity of dialogue rather than from a high-modernist metric that grows more byzantine and opaque each time it gets embedded in another funding formula.


In Rao's account of the modernity machine's birth, Don Quixote marks the end of the medieval world, a knight who "behaves impeccably within a dead symbolic system, and chaos results." I keep thinking we already have our Quixote. He is not a man on a horse. He is a project list, adopted at a regular meeting of the council, submitted on time to Sacramento and reviewed for completeness. He is a pavement score that rises and falls with great ceremony while the pothole on my street stays exactly where it is. Every ritual is performed correctly, and the street never gets fixed.

The Bureau clerk didn't need a better ritual. He went out, counted and asked whether the work had actually happened. That question was the lever all along, and it still is. The tools for asking it now fit in a pocket, ride on the roof of a robotaxi and run on protocols any city could adopt, if we can summon the collective courage.

The Bureau clerk with a notebook had leverage because the count was independent and the public could read it. We will not get that leverage back by building a bigger notebook with the oft floated dream of better performance metrics dashboards. We might get it back by building many small ones, in many places, connected by protocols simple enough that the people doing the work can see their impact and course correct as needed.


A note on AI assistance

This piece was drafted with Claude. It worked from my blyg posts, my Bot Garden notes on permitting and an outline we developed over a long evening of back and forth, which included a round of critique from vgr_zirp, the reconstructed Ribbonfarm voice I like to spar with. Claude also read Venkatesh Rao's World Machines essays and looked up the details on the Pavement Condition Index and SB 1 reporting. The arguments and the stubbornness about potholes are mine.


This is partly why I ran for my local water board. A board seat is a strange place to study legibility theater, since so much of a public meeting is theater in the literal sense. But it is also one node in the kind of network I'm describing, a place where the reports arrive and someone can ask what they actually tell us.

Suggested tags: legibility, permitting, protocols, world machines

read the thread →

Created: Nov 13, 2026

thread

Are the much derided Google+ circles an idea whose time finally has come? In a common fabric world where trust is tied to data and protocols guide where critical information flows, it seems that posts could be published not to the world wide web but rather a mesoscale alternative customized based on a plain text instruction.

[Common fabric is an approach to computing where trust travels with the data itself, and protocols, rather than platforms, govern where information is allowed to flow. Instead of defaulting to the open web or a single company's walled garden, people can share within a space shaped to the context, which is the mesoscale between private and public. The reasoning is laid out in why Common Fabric.]

Google+ circles were 1) very annoying to create in that they required you to go through all your friends and add them manually to different "circles" like high school or college or work or a sport or another hobby 2) conceptually quite clever -- in sum a very OG googley approach that was a bit awkward software engineer geek vibe albeit good natured and friendly. They remind me in that way of wikis which were cool in concept though outside of headline examples like wikipedia really generally poorly maintained.

LLMs have changed that. Tons of people, particularly the sort playing around in the Thicket, use Karpathy style personal knowledge wikis. AI easily acts as a sort of super librarian tagging and organizing and querying all that information you send its way. Very helpul. It strikes me that AI could serve a similar curation function for Google+ style circles on things like the Thicket where you share ideas in larger or smaller circles.

Many people have ideas that they wouldn't want on the wide web with its dark forest dynamics and potential for problems, particularly if you present an attractive attack surface for whatever reason. Instead consider the alternative of a set of overlapping albeit distinct circles of people that you'd want to potentially share with.

read the thread →

Created: Nov 13, 2026

In response to Kyle's blyg ↗

thread · 1 quoted

Thought: why not an option for MCP access to others on your blyg? I wouldn’t really care if someone had read only MCP access to my blyg FWIW. Such a tool would be a way to engage more dynamically across the evolution of ideas. Some of that you can already get with a link and just asking an LLM though this would increase the efficacy.

from pioneering-spirit-blyg.patrickatwater.workers.dev ↗ · snapshot of v1

That's already possible though friction-full. It is a very cool idea. What if you could get read only access w/ rate limits etc just by logging in from your blyg to their blyg? Hmm I'm going to try prototyping this.

I opened an issue for the proposal.

from Kyle's blyg ↗ · snapshot of v2

Thanks for the kind words and that seems like exactly the right approach. As I reflect more this, it'd also enable more tangles, twists and turns in the Thicket as you can enable a permissions for folks to engage more deeply with your content. That feels like a good heuristic for future features. Does this make the Thicket thicker -- more tangled, twisted and crooked timber-esque?

read the thread →

v2

Created: Nov 13, 2026 Most recent: Nov 13, 2026, v2

One fun side effect of blygger and really AI is it's made GitHub fun again. For a while, it became more of a drag, for me at least. Less social and convivial and more pressure to Show Work.

Created: Nov 13, 2026

thread

Mirror worlds

Reading Chetty's newest paper, I am struck by how that approach to causal inference through N=All administrative data plus calibration via RCTs provides a path to realize a big chunk of David Gelenters cyber vision.

[David Gelernter's Mirror Worlds (1991) imagines software models of real-world institutions, such as a city, a school, or a hospital, that mirror their ongoing activity in detail and in real time. Fed continuously by the data those institutions generate, these "mirror worlds" would sit on your desktop and let ordinary people watch, explore, and make sense of complex systems from the inside, rather than relying on expert summaries. The idea anticipates today's digital twins and the dream of seeing a whole system's behavior at once, which is what makes administrative data at N=All feel like a step toward his vision.]

I am excited to try that approach in water use efficiency. I still need to think through and mull the following AI plan.

[The California Data Collaborative's wue-conditions-explorer repo estimates water savings from conservation programs using a matched difference-in-differences design with six controls per participant. As the issue describes it, the repo currently checks the method by confirming that it recovers effects planted in synthetic data. That is necessary but not sufficient, since the planted effects are our own assumptions. The 2018 turf rebate paper by Schmitt, Tull and Atwater had the same gap: no experimental or quasi-experimental benchmark.

Issue 2 proposes closing that gap by borrowing Opportunity Insights' definition of a "digital twin": an observational estimator whose RMSE is comparable to or smaller than that of randomized trials, validated against experiments and valid only within the domain where it was tested. The plan has five steps:

  1. Fix a narrow domain and estimand, such as single-family turf replacement measured in gallons per square foot per year.
  2. Assemble a full-population panel of billing, rebate application and inspection dates, parcel and irrigable area, ET0 and weather, and ACS covariates.
  3. Keep the six-control matched DiD as the baseline and add a comparator, either staggered-adoption DiD or double/debiased machine learning with cross-fitting.
  4. Build a benchmark from quasi-experimental variation, such as rebate budget cutoffs, waitlists, rate changes across agencies or dates, or a randomized rollout order. Add placebo tests with fake rebate dates.
  5. Report RMSE against the benchmark, the validated domain, and the assumption that would let results generalize to other agencies.

The issue names two main threats. Drought-era restrictions may have affected adopters and controls differently, and savings per square foot vary locally. The main practical bottleneck is access to retailer data.]

I also want to reread the Chetty paper more slowly and reflect. I have a strong intution this approach will be very nontrivial.

read the thread →

Created: Nov 13, 2026

Thought: why not an option for MCP access to others on your blyg? I wouldn’t really care if someone had read only MCP access to my blyg FWIW. Such a tool would be a way to engage more dynamically across the evolution of ideas. Some of that you can already get with a link and just asking an LLM though this would increase the efficacy.

Created: Nov 13, 2026

thread

O365 is down so where else to go but into the thicket?

Take my land, poison the sea, You can't take the cloud from me.

Out past the cozy web, where all my friends are home, Down below the dark forest, where the strangers roam, There's a little in-between where the brambles grow, Come on in, mind the thorns, it's the Thicket, so...

Take my land, poison the sea, You can't take the cloud from me.

The lords in their castles let the wild woods rot, All that fog and anarchy, trust is something they forgot. They can't see the tunnels where the roots run deep, Little secret passageways where the dirt-folk creep.

Take my land, poison the sea, You can't take the cloud from me.

Don't wait for it to rain down, don't beg the sky for grace, Build it up from the dirt, find your own sweet place. Every rung's a stick and string, every knot's a friend, Climb on up the Thicket and the ladder never ends.

Take my land, poison the sea, O365 can go down on me, Got a hole in the hedge and a ladder in the loam, In the Thicket I'm in the cloud, and the cloud's my home.

You can't take the cloud from me.

Come friends! Abandon the techno kings and come play.

read the thread →

Created: Nov 13, 2026

Random UX quirk: is there a way to switch from a fragment to a thread on blygger studio? I don’t see that on iOS. I may need to switch over to burrow regardless instead of my weird current hybrid frankensetup.

Created: Nov 13, 2026

thread

Wow!

In the ’70s, most archaeologists thought the explanation for this phenomenon was straightforward. While sea levels were rising, the theory went, coastal regions were simply changing too much to have supported the range of human activities associated with social complexity. But once sea levels settled, a sort of postglacial revolution ensued. “Boom!” Bailey said, describing that view to me. “Suddenly you’ve got this explosion of shell mounds, coastal settlements, fishing technology, dugout canoes, etc., all over the world.”

Bailey entertained doubts about that story early on. It seemed far more likely to him that people had been exploiting coastal environments, which are rich in resources and easy to move around in, for much longer than just the past 6,000 years or so. Wouldn’t it make more sense, he thought, if the “sudden” emergence of cultural complexity along the world’s coasts was simply a reflection of where and when the seas had stopped rising—and stopped covering up all the earlier coastal communities? Archaeologists, he felt, had fallen prey to evidentiary misdirection: The remains of communities on high ground had survived, whereas the original coastal communities had been washed away.

https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/2026/12/aquaterra-ancient-human-migration/689029/?gift=KYf_V7WJ7ea9idDTnMyY9PYpLlJPtgC44FLySHU726g&utm_source=copy-link&utm_medium=social&utm_campaign=share

read the thread →

Created: Nov 12, 2026

Why do people say "crushing it?" What byzantine etymology led us there? On its face the phrase makes no sense. How does doing something very well relate to crushing... Well what exactly? You can crush cans in ana office but very little else is physically crushed. Where did this verbal oddity arise from? I'm curious.

Created: Nov 11, 2026

Like Rome, America has an accretive, amoeba-like quality around a set of fixed principles. These United States also explicitly appeal to Rome in its capitol architecture and in the formal history of the lineage of democracy back to antiquity. Listening to the audiobook After Nations, I’ve been struck by the focus on the globalization of contract law. Rome’s approach to property really has been baked in deeply there. Ideas about ownership and then also responsibility to property are deeply embedded there, to the point of being taken as axiomatic these days, and we quickly forget that many other systems of political economy existed and indeed flourished. I wonder if property law or the Church is the biggest legacy of the Romans? Or perhaps the aqueducts that still stand.

Created: Nov 10, 2026

In response to Notes | Matthew McDowell-Sweet ↗

thread · 1 quoted

To principal or to proxy; that is the question.

WORKING THEORY: The world would be better off if every group or organization consisted entirely of Principals and Proxies. A proxy is someone you trust to do the thing and be in a room on your behalf.

Principals and Proxies ↗

from Notes | Matthew McDowell-Sweet ↗ · snapshot of v1

The world also needs grunts to execute, turn wrenches and all that.

read the thread →

Created: Nov 9, 2026

In response to Notes | Matthew McDowell-Sweet ↗

thread · 1 quoted

Hmmmm.

Features that would be a nightmare on the internet are okay on my computer and mostly okay on private networks. Websites that execute user-generated scripts, control production systems, allow for users to send desktop notifications, spend tokens, or directly prompt my agent. Crazy stuff that would only make sense if everyone was in a committed polycule.

Designing for high trust networks ↗

from Notes | Matthew McDowell-Sweet ↗ · snapshot of v1

I feel like the obvious answer is having dedicated machines and networks for the machines to do stuff that we do things a bit less. Like have machines designed for machines to interact with each other and which don't really matter if others mess up, kinda like how people were setting up open claws on mac minis a while back but on steroids. Lower the consequence.

read the thread →

v2

Created: Nov 8, 2026 Most recent: Nov 10, 2026, v2

In response to Venkatesh Rao's Blyg ↗

thread · 1 quoted

There’s an organic molecule with a crystal structure that has a square hole in it.

from Venkatesh Rao's Blyg ↗ · excerpt of v2

So funnily enough the complement of this enzyme, glycerol, works well as a thickening agent for bubbles. My older daughter turned four Friday. We celebrated at the park this morning and spent the week playing with different mixes of dish soap and glycerol to get the bubble consistency right.

read the thread →

Created: Nov 8, 2026

N00b q: is there a way to have blygger studio auto update?

Created: Nov 7, 2026

Very good sentences:

Federal permitting laws were adopted in the late 1960s and early 1970s, a period of intense cultural change that ushered in a new era of skepticism about big government projects. That skepticism spurred wide-reaching changes in judicial doctrine, bureaucratic norms, and substantive laws. Permitting reform may be necessary to spur more infrastructure development, but it is unlikely to be sufficient without sustained attention to the dense network of laws and practices that have built up around that cultural change. https://nicholasbagley.com/assets/papers/costs-of-federal-permitting.pdf

H/T Marginal Revolution

Created: Nov 7, 2026

In response to Venkatesh Rao's Blyg ↗

thread · 1 quoted

Nice! FT has always seemed more open about frontier possibilities than other newspapers of similar standing. Not sure why. I do remember alphaville exploring abundance economics post GFC. Anywho I digress. Congrats again.

Cognitive mercantilism got covered in the Financial Times

Swap the word intelligence for wealth, Rao argues, and you are harking back to the conceptual universe of the early 18th century. Cognitive mercantilists, who are more interested in capturing wealth than creating it, view intelligence as a precious resource to be tightly controlled by credentialed professionals. Countries and companies scour the world to collect the best brains and hoard them like gold. Conversely, they dismiss the less intelligent “masses” as depreciating assets at risk of becoming superfluous humans.

from Venkatesh Rao's Blyg ↗ · snapshot of v1

read the thread →

Created: Nov 6, 2026

In response to And Yet Here We Are 🚀 ↗

thread · 1 quoted

I have high desire to build things with AI but low for getting into fitness again. Considering a reward ladder where i’m allowed to build increasingly complex (and fun) things with Claude around fitness only when I have sufficient data captured to warrant that feature.

from And Yet Here We Are 🚀 ↗ · snapshot of v1

What kind of physical activity do you enjoy out of curiosity? A silly riff on the idea of linking irl fitness activity to the digital world https://pioneeringspirit.xyz/forging-the-future-protocols-of-strength-and-spirit

read the thread →

Created: Nov 6, 2026

Any Bluey fans in the Thicket?

Created: Nov 6, 2026

In response to Notes | Matthew McDowell-Sweet ↗

thread · 1 quoted

The Agile delivery section of the GOV.UK Service Manual is, I suspect, the most widely cited and least carefully read document of practical importance in British public administration. Everyone in Whitehall digital has a view on it. Very few people have a working relationship with it. What most departments have instead is a cargo cult.

from Notes | Matthew McDowell-Sweet ↗ · excerpt of v1

First +=1 for throwing llm ed vgr at tangled org challenges.

Second, regarding agile in gov, I wonder if it's inevitable for those methods to get cargo culted without upstream shifts in civil service, procurement, and internal processes.

Third and finally, I have to say UKDS always looked so shiny from across the pond, like a place where digital government was actually taken seriously.

read the thread →

Created: Nov 6, 2026

How many books could have been a blog post? A lot of airport New York times bestseller type of books offer up 80% of their insight in the kindle sample. I was preai and is the only thing that's only accelerating as there's more and more things that are published as a book but are really not quite the standalone single authored deep perspective the word book implies. We are obviously living through something like the shift from oral to written and then to type set information transfer culture. Still feels emergent... I'm enjoying exploring and blygging!

Created: Nov 6, 2026

Is there a word for the conflicted emotions around the idea that the thicketmah grow crowded and less of a small cozy enclave? That words here may ricochet around the wide web with all its dark forest dynamics, that free and open inquiry may smother under the weight of attention, that more reach for blygger may lead to better discourse more broadly...

Created: Nov 5, 2026

thread

What are the most successful examples of impactful data standards emerging from legislatively mandated collaborations?

My sense is that formalization via legislation is usually the last step. Or obliquely the first in that a legislative mandate or fear thereof catalyzes the collaboration requisite for standardization.

Reading through the proposed permitting streamlining bill, the data standards in support of new digital services jumped out at me. Particularly this bit about compliance:

"a list of Federal agencies that are not yet fully compliant with the data standards published under section 3 and the minimum functional requirements described in section 5(a)(2), along with their progress toward compliance;" https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-119hr4503eh/pdf/BILLS-119hr4503eh.pdf

So if an agency is obstinate, which of course never is overt, what recourse does the President's Council of Environmental Quality have? Public shame -- really? LOL.

I read it as a positive signal that there's more awareness that operational approaches from the sixties and seventies are obsolete though am pessimistic that this type of approach will work. See AB 1755 the open and transparent water data act in CA.

This blog post is canonical and has been a lighthouse for me (Jay from UC Davis is a legend): https://californiawaterblog.com/2018/03/26/californias-water-data-problems-are-symptoms-of-inchoate-science-and-technical-activities/

read the thread →

Created: Nov 5, 2026

Did IT folks talk about search in 1992? My sense is no. I wonder what new concepts will be commonplace in the AI era to typical IT folks though not in the water widely today.

Created: Nov 5, 2026

Dirt up AI examples -- sometimes I wonder about the disconnect between the epistemic cultures of digital cloud techie types and folks that deal with stuff irl. A buddy from HS who does digital marketing for fancy global folks shared a draft email for my (successful!) local water board campaign. There were a lot of factual errors. It was a clever use of AI in some ways though I wonder about 1) how AI gets local data wrong and 2) a sort of cavalier cloud attitude about what's useful. Regarding 1) that's not something that fancier models will solve per say. There are data availability and organization issues. See WhatWaterCosts.org for a great protocolized approach to address those. Regarding 2) that's why I think that as AI deploys there will be a lot more dirt up innovation from folks that have that local knowledge. That's more scarce. The cloud central stuff is increasingly getting commodified further and further upstream.

Created: Nov 5, 2026

thread

Rewilding Permitting Protocols

Notes from a week of sparring with Goldratt and a ghost of Ribbonfarm

Earlier this week I read a Niskanen Center piece on how a Senate permitting package could speed up geothermal, and I asked Claude what Eliyahu Goldratt's The Goal would make of it. The proposal leans on 30-day deadlines and a new ombudsman. That is the kind of fix the book's hero spends a hundred pages learning to distrust, because asking more of a system without examining the system mostly produces expediters.

So I went looking for the system, or at least for what the Government Accountability Office had written about it. The details make anyone who has worked in a public agency wince. One developer reported that some Bureau of Land Management offices accept permit materials by email while others want mailed forms with wet signatures. Developers say "exploration" to mean drilling for the resource, while BLM's regulations use the word differently, so people file the wrong application. The agency's geothermal handbooks have been in draft since at least 2022, and one Nevada office GAO describes was 60 percent vacant.

None of that is in the statute. It is the actual protocol, the one that lives in the habits of each field office, and it differs from the one in the documents. I have started calling the practice of looking at it first rewilding: finding out what is really happening before deciding what to fix.


Goldratt supplies the method. Find where throughput dies, measure the waiting separately from the working, and resist speeding up steps that are not the constraint. GAO's numbers suggest the constraint may not be where the reformers are pointing. Nominated land took 455 days on average to reach a lease sale on BLM land, and about a fifth of nominated acres were rejected because land use plans never allowed geothermal leasing in the first place. Meanwhile, approved drilling permits climbed from 7 in 2019 to 68 in 2024.

I took the same question to vgr_zirp, my reconstructed Ribbonfarm sparring partner, who rejected the premise. In his telling the permit office is rarely the constraint. The queue is a symptom of a political settlement, and speeding it up only delivers you to the wall faster. He is probably right about housing and CEQA, where the wall is a lawsuit. I am less sure he is right about geothermal on federal land, where most of what GAO describes is ambiguity, variation between offices, and too few geologists. Those are problems Goldratt knew how to work on.


Iceland offers a picture of the alternative. Parliament approves a Master Plan that sorts proposed power projects into use, on hold, or protection, and the result binds municipal land-use planning. The argument over where happens once, in public, before a developer is standing at a counter holding a form. The protocol is written down instead of rediscovered office by office. It also arrives in very large batches. One project I read about waited more than four years between reaching the steering committee and a favorable recommendation, which still needs a parliamentary vote.

Which brings me back to the wet signature. A protocol that lives in habit can be changed by a handbook, a tracker, and a decision about who is allowed to say no. A protocol that lives in a political settlement takes a different kind of work and a lot more time. I don't yet know how to tell, from the outside, which kind of wall a given permit is waiting at. That seems like a test worth someone building.

Suggested tags: permitting, geothermal, protocols, infrastructure

read the thread →

v2

Created: Nov 4, 2026 Most recent: Nov 4, 2026, v2

In response to Venkatesh Rao's Blyg ↗

thread · 1 quoted

Congress, the institution has broken down due to an internal split between blindly proceduralist centrists who don’t want real deliberations at all, and extremists whom to turn every vote into an internal power struggle crisis.

from Venkatesh Rao's Blyg ↗ · excerpt of v1

Yes and congress hasn't declared war since 1942. The growth of unelected de facto legislating in the administrative and judicial functions also emphasizes the hollowing out of Congress. Many factors at place here.

Trumpism has taken things to such an absurd tragicomic level that there's a small silver lining that we might get much needed structural reform.

read the thread →

Created: Nov 4, 2026

In response to Venkatesh Rao's Blyg ↗

thread · 1 quoted

Their only real role is to be “not Republican” this election cycle.

from Venkatesh Rao's Blyg ↗ · excerpt of v2

Another interesting question: what happens to the Republicans now? It's hard to imagine Rs challenging trump. I can see a purple fusion emerging on the dem side. Abundance types are sorta a new spin on center right and neoliberalism. I remember you vgr had a chart in prolegomena to psychohistory that feels prescient.

https://ribbonfarm.com/2017/11/30/prolegomena-to-any-dark-age-psychohistory/

read the thread →

v2

Created: Nov 3, 2026 Most recent: Nov 3, 2026, v2

In response to Venkatesh Rao's Blyg ↗

thread · 1 quoted

Also this is obviously one of the most critical elections in my life in the US. Probably the most, because in other consequential elections in some ways we didn’t quite know what we were signing up for on at least one side. Now it’s all known quantities and bad quantities which makes it business as usual in some sense.

from Venkatesh Rao's Blyg ↗ · excerpt of v2

That’s been said pretty much every election during my voting / adult life (since Obama in 2008). I think it holds this year though.

A sidebar and actually bigger story than just the Trump / not Trump stuff will be the underlying constitutional issue if congress reasserts itself. That branch has been in decline for decades. Theoretically if the system works as intended it should grow some spine and reassert it prerogatives. We’ll see.

read the thread →

Created: Nov 3, 2026

Do folks in The Thicket habitually update posts? I find myself more likely to reply and update to other folks. I think that there needs to be some sort of MCP like integration into a client like Burrow to make that more native for me at least. I’d want to ask what are all the posts I wrote about topic X and maybe stub some old stuff and then version them. I’m also not really sure how the updates flow into the feed of the Thicket. This may just be me and something I need to play around with more.

Created: Nov 3, 2026

In response to Venkatesh Rao's Blyg ↗

thread · 1 quoted

I'm more-or-less a single issue voter — severely weaken Trump's movement. The odd thing is that doesn't make me necessarily want the democrats to win big as it's long been my hypothesis that the only way low-information Trump votes would abandon him is if Trump just completely screws up — which he's been doing a wonderful job at in the 2nd term by surrounding himself loyalists.

from Kyle's blyg ↗ · excerpt of v1

Heh I independently said the same thing in my update to my post just now. Only difference is I think the democrats do need to win big. Decisively enough that there’s no doubt Trumpism is not just dead but an embarrassment people want to put behind them and move on from.

from Venkatesh Rao's Blyg ↗ · snapshot of v1

Seems you got that. Of course the real direction of the country’s future will be set down ballot in obscure local water district races :P

read the thread →

Created: Nov 3, 2026

In response to New Nature ↗

thread · 1 quoted

Our contemporary understanding of nature feels (rather appropriately) natural but is in fact a very recently constructed idea.

from New Nature ↗ · excerpt of v4

Perhaps worth also touching on the development of the idea of man as something apart from the environment rather than part of an integrated world.

read the thread →

Created: Nov 2, 2026

thread

Life scripts -- I was catching up with some old friends from college a few weekends back and they commented that there's not really great shows that provide models for navigating life these days. Some thoughts and conjectures:

  1. Today's world is upended so we're off the map.
  2. Past scripts have been thrown out and nothing has replaced them.
  3. Divergence and media fragmentation have made relevant scripts harder to find. 3a divergence has made aligning on common life scripts and having a shared vocabulary, set of examples is much more difficult.
  4. This is a problem primarily in places like the states where economic shifts have pushed economic possibilities like a large single family home like those most boomers enjoyed out of reach for the upcoming generations.

Number 1 feels wrong in the sense that history is absolutely wild and there's lots of potentially relevant data points. I think there's something to 2 though it's not the whole story. 3a strikes me as definitely a factor. 4 is key context though I feel 3a compounds it.

There's not just shared struggle but a sort of sense of bewilderment.

read the thread →

Created: Nov 2, 2026

Dirt up benchmarks

How much better have llms made:

  • roomba performance in your home
  • car touchscreen user experiences
  • smart irrigation controller scheduling
  • changing a tire
  • cooking a casserole
  • what else?

Created: Nov 2, 2026

In response to Samp Software and other things ↗

thread · 1 quoted

A loose thought: when will human experts stop being the gold standard for ground truthing niche classification problems? That's already shifted in somewhat in domains like radiology but even there there's issues with classifying in the wild of lots of hospital with messy sensors. Is this something that will generalize in the coming years with AI?

from blyg.pioneeringspirit.xyz ↗ · snapshot of v1

In some domains, plenty of it will be automated - a lot of it already is! AI broadly defined will precategorize everything easy - or things that are hard for humans but easy for machines - and the human will classify everything that is left.

I think of the old 50s sitcoms - the I Love Lucys etc - where e.g. Lucy gets a job on the candy inspection line and has to review every candy (eventually she falls behind and eats them, for comedic effect). Today a camera reviews them all as they pass at high speed.

But someone is setting the criteria, creating cutoffs, reviewing edge cases, etc.

Even "it has shifted in radiology" - when did the shift start? When AI started classifying? When easy access to imaging machines created false color images, or on a particular layer of a 3D scan.

(A special note - my first stub, let's see if I did it right.)

from Samp Software and other things ↗ · snapshot of v2

Stub works! Welcome to the thicket.

My motivating example was fish counts using sonar. Realistically both the human expert annotator and the AI are wrong compared to what's going on in the world. I agree there already is a lot of and will be more automation. I wonder how much will require use case specific codes. Reality has a surprising amount of detail and all that.

read the thread →

Created: Nov 2, 2026

A loose thought: when will human experts stop being the gold standard for ground truthing niche classification problems? That's already shifted in somewhat in domains like radiology but even there there's issues with classifying in the wild of lots of hospital with messy sensors. Is this something that will generalize in the coming years with AI?

Created: Nov 2, 2026

thread

Protocolizing Potholes

The Protocol Institutes November book writing month starting today offers a prompt: take a field you’re familiar with and reexamine that space through the lens of protocols. I have a lot of thoughts about potholes and smart cities stuff. I’m not prioritizing putting those all together formally into book form by the end of November but do intend to do some riffing.[0] This piece is a first stub of that larger smart cities / civic tech inquiry.

Potholes are a high visible unit of city performance. Many mayors focus a nontrivial piece their tenure on the problem. “Fixing potholes” has become a synechdoche for nonpartisan good government through better tech or improved business practices or the like. Potholes also served as a key focal point for the Bureau of Municipal Research. In the early days of the foundational effort, the BMR counted the potholes actually fixed in NYC. (Rather than relying on the biased reports of the political patronage machine. Or at least that’s my recollection.)

Waymo recently announced that they were sharing data on potholes with the City and County of San Francisco. The many cameras and other sensors provide a tool to show where potholes are and inform city management practices. This information can be useful. Cities don’t actually know where all the potholes are. Instead laser vans, windshield surveys and 311 provide an operational picture of where potholes are. Those information are used to allocate moneys for which roads to streets.[1]

For a long time, I thought that was a data problem. The root of the issue was the wrong information being used to make street management decisions and the solution was using the right information. Looking downstream at how that information gets utilized in decisions from the budgetary to the operational level, I’m now convinced the problem is protocolized.

In the states, funding for cities from higher levels of government tends to be tied to the Pavement Condition Index. I did a bunch of public records act requests from cities across the country on how they track and manage potholes. The divergence of data formats and practices was illuminating. It’s quite the mess. That’s obvious though. Look around: the public sector struggles to deliver these days!

Taking a more protocolized lens, some questions to explore and potentially follow up on:

  1. What are the tradeoffs between efficiency and thoroughness in the current equilibrium? What are the leverage points to expand the ETTO frontier?
  2. What is the current system solving for? What are the incentivizes of different actors from vendors fixing the streets to consultants crunching street quality numbers to civil servants managing the programs and all the specific folks therein?
  3. What is the historical evolution of the pavement condition index? What other standards does it mirror and where might be the leverage points to evolve that index?
  4. Where might an integrated pilot deploying not just novel sensors but also looking at
  5. What is the right temporal perspective for shifting pothole maintenance? Potholes typically go through a seasonal cadence with weather. Modern roads like many other civilly engineered infrastructure goes on a generational scale of several decades.
  6. How is pothole maintenance a synecdoche for the larger shift to cyberphysical infrastructure and evolution of civil engineering? See the argument in Real Engineers Deliver Results that engineering is defined by whether things work in the world, not by credentials or process, which is a useful yardstick for civil engineering as it takes on cyberphysical systems.
  7. How do other cities globally fix their potholes? What are the consequences of public contracting procedures in places like the states? What are possible alternative protocols to improve the situation?

[0] My plan in November is to iterate on a very rough children’s book that I have ~31% written called _A Portal to Primeland. [1] Not this a US based perspective. For more context on ARGO’s past work in potholes, see:

[ARGO's street quality identification device, or SQUID, was our attempt to test whether cities could measure road conditions with cheap, open hardware instead of relying only on laser vans, windshield surveys, and 311 complaints. The project documents a low-cost sensor package that can ride along on ordinary vehicles and capture location-tagged data about how rough the pavement is. The idea was that a city could collect street quality information continuously, as a byproduct of the driving it already does, rather than in occasional and expensive survey passes. The build write-up is meant to be reproducible, so other governments and civic technologists can adapt the device for their own needs. In hindsight, SQUID also showed how much the value of better sensing depends on whether a city's existing processes can absorb the data.]

read the thread →

v2

Created: Nov 1, 2026 Most recent: Nov 1, 2026, v2

In response to Kyle's blyg ↗

thread · 1 quoted

Research says community spaces is part protocol/interface doesn't and part founder effects (which are quite powerful and persistent).

from Kyle's blyg ↗ · excerpt of v2

Is founder effects the full spectrum of things though for something like Reddit? I’m not super active there though the rule set guiding mods is very important yeah?

Thanks for the points btw. I learned something :)

read the thread →

Created: Nov 1, 2026

In response to Venkatesh Rao's Blyg ↗

thread · 1 quoted

blygger feel like it successfully occupies the meso-scale space between blogs and microblogs

from Venkatesh Rao's Blyg ↗ · excerpt of v1

Yeah I agree. It reminds me a bit of a technical conference where you can have more in depth discussions as well as powerfully, insightful nuggets in a short span.

On a secant I was talking to a buddy from undergrad who does open source computational chemistry, and he had recently started a bear blog. So there’s a random piece of anecdata for you on potential comps.

read the thread →

Created: Nov 1, 2026

In response to Venkatesh Rao's Blyg ↗

thread · 1 quoted

Election 2026

Strikes me that blygging is a great way to log your evolving impressions during an election.

from Venkatesh Rao's Blyg ↗ · excerpt of v1

The States

Electoral

  • Team Apathy seems to really be winning over the combined forces of Red and Blue.
  • Polling seems to have gotten more inaccurate. Part of this seems to have been the result of 1) more focus on the polls along with 2) the shift away from landlines.
  • This may be the end of Trumpism. The dude seems very old and unhinged even to committed supporters I know.
  • The Iran Not War and the economy has been a bigger deal for Trumps coalition than many outside MAGA world realize methinks. There’s words that offend you and then actions that affect you as they say.
  • Germandering likely will backfire in unexpected ways. There was a big story 1-2 years back on how teams Red and Blue were carving up more seats. The math of Redistricting though is that trying to spread out voters to gain seats leads increases the brittleness and susceptibility of wave elections.

Governing (Issues to track the next two years)

  • Will Congress reassert itself as a functioning constitutional branch? (I’m not holding my breadth.)
  • Will the growing consensus about the need to modernize government operations result in meaningful reform?

California

  • The governor’s race has really disappointed me. It feels like the blob machine candidate versus the sloptivism promise the world alternative. So much for a serious and sober dialogue on the many problems we face. The race was well summed up by one undergrad at the debate hosted at the Claremont Colleges (my Alma mater): “well that was an absolute mess.”
  • I bet that the wealth tax fails either outright or in terms of the alternative poison pills that Sergei put on. (The initiatives will be a good indicator of where the CA electorate is trending on a political compass over the medium, better than the gubernatorial non-race which is intertwined with the national partisanship.)
  • I bet that Raman has it. There’s enough anti-incumbency spirit in the air to take down Bass. Also a piece of anecdota: I’ve seen around a half dozen Raman signs but none from Bass.

Global elections

  • Israel — It seems that Netanyahu may find a way to squirrel his way into holding onto power (sadly)?
  • Brazil — Lula won. Meta’s glitch favoring Bolsanero’s son strikes me as the sort of thing that really emphasizes the need for user control of the algorithms. That was on Muse though also applies to the feed and really is a data point in favor of open protocols like blygger.
  • This may just be motivated reasoning on my part but ousting Orban earlier this year feels like a big deal.
  • One governing trend to watch: the Spanish series of rail crashes feel like a bad omen in a normally high capacity and competent train country.

More broadly, as country after country has a battle between the nationalist right and blob-like left, I am struck by the common political patterns. I’ve been enjoying the book After Nations on audible the past month or so:

Rana Dasgupta's After Nations argues that the nation-state, long our default container for politics, has been hollowed out by global finance, digital networks, and corporate power that operate beyond any government's control. As governments lose the ability to deliver on their promises, he suggests, voters turn to nostalgia, populism, and strongmen, and we will need new forms of political organization to replace the old ones.

Cui Bono

Stateside, I have definitely been on team Not Trump, sometimes team Very Much Not Trump (which I suppose lapses / gets caricatured into TDS. I am a candidate for local office in an anytown suburb of So Cal. See my water board campaign website at AtwaterForFMWD.com.

I have found focusing my political energies on something that I can control and potentially impact much healthier than the digitally supercharged bizarre spin cycle we’ve lived through. My general joke about the last decade is I’d be hard pressed to get my high school self circa 2005 to take seriously what has happened.

Lastly once upon a time I wrote a book, A New California Dream, that argues for a constitutional convention to modernize our democratic and administrative procedures in our state. I’ve had a bit of a reformist streak.

read the thread →

Created: Oct 30, 2026

thread

The measurement problem in carbon removal

Here's a little problem that's actually a big challenge for how we decarbonize in time to avoid calamity: measurement.

I spent a lot of time working on that through the specific regional issue of water efficiency back when I was running the CA water data collaborative. There are a lot of measurement issues with how much water is saved as those calculations are used to determine incentive amounts.

Indoor water usage which has largely mechanical determinations of deltas was more in the comfort zone of legigibility seeking institutions. Indoor average point estimates for the water use change for a single family home with 4 people make sense as toilets are used however much they're used.

Outdoor water use which involves a lot of behavioral shifts is a bit different. Outdoor watering though involves a lot of behavior and variation such as specific plant types, microclimates, whether people remember to water, attitudes towards new plants etc. The point is the variation is wider and that takes different strategies.

There's a lot of lessons for carbon removal and mitigation. Consider the following charts and specifically look at promising methods like mineralization or regenerative agriculture.

Source: https://www.stateofcdr.org/asset/SoCDR-Ed3_Chapter-10_Final.pdf

The webpage has a nice description of what VCLs mean and the categorization methodology: https://carbonplan.org/research/cdr-verification-explainer

I have a bias for lower cost "good enough" measurements that are actionable rather than analysis paralysis seeking "ideal data." This is important as the costs of these technologies and methods are not fixed! How those cost ranges evolves is a function of their learning rate which will be determined by deployments.

Having good enough measurements to confidently fund various approaches will be critical. So far industry has had to lead the way through the Frontier Carbon initiative. Ultimately however the scale of the decarbonization challenge will require public funding. That will require more and better measurement to deploy.

Remote sensing is improving by leaps and bounds but in my experience always benefits from calibration by in situ sensors. I wonder why a place like California does not have such a sensor network. There is a highly successful precedent in the California Irrigation Management Information System which calculates reference ET using a modeled approach from measured wind speed, temperature, solar radiation etc.

There are various scientific sensor networks such Fluxnet which serves as a network of sensor networks. Those seem to be geared towards scientific modeling rather than the applied problem of measuring and incentivizing specific decarbonization. Regenerative ag would benefit from a public network of carbon flux data along with interpolation a la CIMIS, spatial CIMIS, Open ET.

I still don't have a great sense of cost and the logistics involved though am curious to learn more. Thanks for reading as I learn and explore in public.

TK

read the thread →

v3

Created: Oct 30, 2026 Most recent: Oct 30, 2026, v3

Suspect narratives

An eccentric adjunct albeit old college intro English prof had us all create accounts on Daily Kos and post as part of a project. We were supposed to generate a suspect narrative in the style of Daniel Defoe’s journal of a plague year.[1] This proved prescient in a couple of ways: 1) suspect narratives are now the default on the internet of a thousand lies and 2) well the plague year was a Big Thing.

I wonder what something fun and playful would look like on blygger? My mind goes to something whimsical like the puzzle tradition of CalTech and MIT.

[1] Arguably the first novel.

Created: Oct 29, 2026

One of the biggest side effects of AI in my little world of water is folks aren’t skeptical of digital in the same way. A decade back when we were starting the CA data collaborative, there was a lot of skepticism about how it was very ethereal and ephemeral. That hasn’t really changed in that the use cases are complex and can be abstract. (Try for a thought experiment to explain the value of better measurement of a specific programs outcomes to someone in the 19th century. Compare that to say 10x cheaper rocket launches which have a simple ELI5 appeal.) The amount of money and attention in AI has made it harder to ignore though.

v2

Created: Oct 29, 2026 Most recent: Oct 29, 2026, v2

Dawn of the doorman economy?

As AI automates more and more in the coming years (decades?), the simple doorman offers a useful parable for a potential shape of things to come. There are many ways to lock doors with a code or a key. Today there are automations. The doorman also signals status, helps keep away the riff raff, can also help take bags to a cab, and provide a miscellaneous set of services beyond the simple act of opening and closing a door. ATMs show a similar parallel with today’s rise of higher end doorman types (well they wouldn’t call themselves that) though offering concierge services for private wealth management and like. With the concentration of wealth and ease of automation, expect more doorman type of services.

Created: Oct 29, 2026

In response to Venkatesh Rao's Blyg ↗

thread · 6 quoted

Protocols Over Paeans to Techno-Progress

This reframing of AI as a variable purpose technology is subtle and important.

AI is the most variable-value technology ever invented. One sign is that you don’t know whether a token is worth a penny or a million dollars without knowing what problem it’s being applied to under what conditions. So it’s best to think of it as a variable-purpose technology rather than a general-purpose technology. This is extremely weird. While many economic goods have values that depend on context, especially under distorted market conditions, this is the first good whose value depends entirely on context, even in undistorted perfect market conditions.

from Venkatesh Rao's Blyg ↗ · excerpt of v2

One mapping I'm noodling is between variable-purpose tech and soft technologies, pulling from the definition from VGR's Breaking Smart essay series. It strikes me that many other adjacent technologies like double entry accounting protocols or various writing technologies have a variable quality. It's not clear prima facie from the technology if the value is pennies or something much more. Or spreadsheets are a more modern example. That tool could be creating trivial economic value in planning a birthday party or be the foundation for shifting titanic sums of money in a financial model.

One thing I've been mulling is the pace of adoption at different layers. AI is slow to permeate infrastructure though in fifty years its hard to imagine that we will not use it in a meaningful manner to build, maintain and operate critical systems. That shift though will take time. There will be a ton of highly variable deployments including lots of vaporware and extremely inefficient rabbit holes that ended up going nowhere.

Tim O'Reilly has a piece out that makes the point we should be looking at incentives as we look to make this technology actually beneficial. There is a lot of cloud down thinking though much to agree with such as:

We’re spending enormous amounts of money making AI more capable, but comparatively little effort figuring out the mechanisms that will turn those capabilities into opportunities for everyone else. https://asimovaddendum.substack.com/p/human-pilled?utm_source=share&utm_medium=android&r=1fnfr

China has prizes for AI deployments to improve agricultural production. I don't get why there aren't more ambitious efforts here in California on how we can use AI to improve critical infrastructure, speed up our broken permitting systems, obliterate the horrific administrative burdens of modern society (both public and also private aspects like dealing with healthcare), etc etc. There was a new Ren Phil funded effort on AI for public benefits and there's so much more opportunity. A few:

Creating a world where anyone from anywhere has not just a right to repair but the ability to enage with robots on free and open terms in a level marketplace.

thread ↗ · excerpt of v1

Refactoring institutions from the information flows up to enable AI native data operations and showing rather than telling what that reimagination means.

thread ↗ · excerpt of v1

Develop a global dataset of every metered drop of water sold on our pale blue dot (and while we're at it, do electricity too, along with gas and randomized instrumentation to get trash)

thread ↗ · excerpt of v1

Build a network of applied researchers in the spirit of the OG Bureau of Municipal Research that pioneered the archictecure for modern public administration that is now gumming up its gears.

thread ↗ · excerpt of v1

Develop New Nature as a first class concept for making sense of the world we're entering and articulate what terraforming as a viable path for actually winning this damn world war zero rather than obliterating humanity.

thread ↗ · excerpt of v1

Today there is a real need to show rather than tell the benefits of AI, which for normal folks cannot be separated from the larger shifts to digital and how that's shifted how we live, work and play.

It takes me back to online music about twenty years ago. Creators were putting commercial music in their YouTube videos, and the music companies were sending takedown notices and threatening to sue. YouTube’s answer was, how about we help you monetize it instead? Its Content ID system gave rights holders a choice: block the video, or leave it up and collect revenue from the ads that run against it. Most chose to get paid, and that helped give rise to the creator economy.

Context is important. Here's what Claude has to show about the impact on the music industry's recorded revenue.

That's roughly $19 billion in 2015 dollars in 1995 against about $7 billion in 2015, at retail value.

Another story is that YouTube wasn't a benevolent helpful friendly techie just building and creating and so enlightened but actually just Silicon Valley mopping up the remnants of the music industry after it has been obliterated by peer to peer piracy. The creator economy is brutal and a small solace for the musicians I know. Sure there are some isolated success stories but like look around: things are harder for normal people. O'Reilly again:

The game I want us to play is one in which all of us build the future together, so that we control this wonderful new wave of technology for ourselves.

Yes and that will take more of what we saw the last few decades. We are living through epic, quite turbulent times. This will require a more muscular competent state. Civic tech is just the start. It'll take new protocols beyond digital tools like MCP but also new institutional structures along with the courage to let go of specific obsolete institutions.[1]

Each prior variable purpose technology like counting or writing or the oft invoked printing press resulted in profound reshapings of how we structure society. We ought to have the courage to dream and act at a similar scale, particularly given the size of the challenges we face.

[1] (That's why I'm running for my local water board. It's also a good reason why to read widely and engage in the Blygosphere as a sensemaking institution as we navigate large civilization scale shifts.)

read the thread →

Created: Oct 29, 2026

Special Assignments

Working in an innovation role, I find myself parachuting into a variety of projects and needing to quickly align tempo along with booting up context. The following scene from Andor season one often comes to mind.

You are Imperial Private Clem. You’re a sentry from the Alkenzi Airbase transferred for special duty.

The series is really a quite excellent treatment of bureaucracy and the forces that motivate someone to break from the internal line. Even if abstractly the empire is horrific, that's not what motivates someone to join the rebellion per say. It's something they did to a loved one. Or money. Or something else specific and tangible.

That really aligns not in the grand space opera sense but rather in the need for specific and particular motivations to convince someone to go beyond their normal day to day job duties and do something different (you know innovate), no matter how abstractly sensible. Again:

Can you walk like a soldier?

v2

Created: Oct 29, 2026 Most recent: Oct 29, 2026, v2

In response to Venkatesh Rao's Blyg ↗

thread · 1 quoted

way to stay active on farcaster without becoming a network-stater. Though that thing gave me enough ick I don’t know that I want to post anyway. But nice idea.

from Venkatesh Rao's Blyg ↗ · excerpt of v1

Network State claims to be building a digital set of Singapores though really reminds me more of South Point: one of the off strip casino’s in Vegas. Lots of control, lots of conditioning to keep the users compliant and still pulling the levers on the slot machines. Or whatever silly degenerate stuff is the flavor of the month there now.

read the thread →

Created: Oct 29, 2026

Tempo

Sometimes I wonder where and how I stumbled on that book. Or really the specific path. I read and actually got into drawing some of the diagrams when I was bored as a young analyst at a public finance consulting firm. Anyway I find my mind going back to that and doodling a few of the circles to track the cadence of a pitch just now.

Beyond playing with the diagrams, I also find myself wondering if the implicit protocol of PowerPoint for software pitches will shift with AI. Really hoping so actually. It’s trivially easy to make a deck that has a shiny UX and use cases. This ties into the experience of AI for many folks outside the Elysium and adjacent to the cloud fortress. A downstream result of AI is more vaporware. I remember getting a demo that really tickled me at one point where it was clearly just a loveable site with a lot of claims layered on top of a single case study with a city. Ha.

Created: Oct 29, 2026

In response to And Yet Here We Are 🚀 ↗

thread · 4 quoted

Building the Bridge Atlas

For my fellow glass bead enthusiasts in The Thicket: What if we look beyond convention and maps and rules?[1]

“I understand now that boundaries between noise and sound are conventions. All boundaries are conventions, waiting to be transcended. One may transcend any convention if only one can first conceive of doing so.” - Cloud Atlas

Look beyond the ascii art and one see shapes, alterations as replies hand off from one creator to another.

B1] What is not dying in the Gramsci Gap?

from And Yet Here We Are 🚀 ↗ · excerpt of v1

│ ├── [B2] Places are made of slightly dead Spaces

│ │ │ ├── [B4] (placeholder)

Music offers ways to show a series of soloists, a concept made famous by the acclaimed novel and now movie quoted at the start of this post.

Listen along here if you like to what my ai amanuensis put together based on the description from the novel Cloud Atlas: https://claude.ai/artifact/T7t12G3JuEJzxpcVh1RW4t

(Note I still prefer and am listening to the Cloud Atlas Sextet score from the movie, which notably adheres less to the description in the book than this AI generated riff.) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=C2U-lL_qdTI

Such joy and levity and spirit... AI offers us tools of profound conviviality. For all the talk of AI as superintelligence or a new general purpose intelligence and blather about the end of the world (or people closer to the dirt wondering what all the fuss is about and if this is yet another Pets dot com style fiasco...), I have found that the framing of AI as:

most variable-value technology ever invented. One sign is that you don’t know whether a token is worth a penny or a million dollars without knowing what problem it’s being applied to under what conditions. So it’s best to think of it as a variable-purpose technology rather than a general-purpose technology. This is extremely weird. While many economic goods have values that depend on context, especially under distorted market conditions, this is the first good whose value depends entirely on context, even in undistorted perfect market conditions.

from Venkatesh Rao's Blyg ↗ · excerpt of v2

Perhaps that explains the profound angst so many feel today. AI upends deeply held collective and individual assumptions. An important task then is to create conviviality and space for showing rather than telling its uses, bringing the promethean fire to warm the tribe, cook food, and light the way.

The fire of AI is here, and events like proof dumps are still rippling through our collective sensemaking apparatuses. Terrance Tao talks of an epochal shift to proof abundance. What does that mean? Folks in the Internet of a Thousand Lies use lazy lay definitions of mathematics, as if that area of human inquiry had a consensus definition.[2]

A college roommate of mine loved the book Godel, Escher, Bach: an eternal golden braid. I never read that though it struck me as Glass Bead-like, an intellectual interplay of abstract patterns across domains. That spirit of intellectual fervor and ferment is what attracts me to blygging.

AI offers an infinitely patient librarian. Transcludes and updates offer the ability to learn and share and engage in dialogue. What if we used these tools to not just engage in the abstract sleepwalking of a mathematicians symbolic manipulation[3] but to dream, to share new frontiers, even if they are not of the stars but rather the reflections of muddy puddles, the world discovered anew through a child's eyes in a backyard?

We are embarking on a strange chapter in humanity's story.

Is the prime radiant project something that can be actually useful or an idle hobby of a few internet randos? Are these protocol connections intellectual abstractions or useful tools for solutions that touch dirt?[4]

Blygs offer ample subjects, enough fodder for fertile discussion to last a thousand organic lifetimes and even more artificial explorations of symbolic manipulations.

Your subjects are already abundant: protocols, thickets, Prime Radiant, AI, capitalism, geography, writing, institutions, history.

from And Yet Here We Are 🚀 ↗ · excerpt of v1

Might not blygs serve as a scaffolding for a new weird and wonderful Bridge Atlas between the fragmented fediverse, our new town square that's already gone digital but which is more like a Wild West saloon than the civilized salon we need to discuss and dialogue and yes occasionally debate matters of the day?

An intellectual I admire once offered the idea that blockchain offered the tooling to end the upstream digital ad crazed cacophony that's amplified the culture war. The blyg protocol feels flexible and simple and extensible enough to serve as a "small piece, loosely joining" the fractal and fragmented dark forest of the internet. Cloud Atlas ends as a circle as humanity's far future comes back into the past, with our technologies doomed by our own desires.

Rather than today's bizarre and broken timeline that so many seem to be resigned into, or really many resigned into garden tending as folks tire of hyperventillated fearmongering about the charybdis and scyllas of the day... Why not...

  • Creating a world where anyone from anywhere has not just a right to repair but the ability to enage with robots on free and open terms in a level marketplace.
  • Refactoring institutions from the information flows up to enable AI native data operations and showing rather than telling what that reimagination means.
  • Develop a global dataset of every metered drop of water sold on our pale blue dot (and while we're at it, do electricity too, along with gas and randomized instrumentation to get trash)
  • Build a network of applied researchers in the spirit of the OG Bureau of Municipal Research that pioneered the archictecure for modern public administration that is now gumming up its gears.
  • Develop New Nature as a first class concept for making sense of the world we're entering and articulate what terraforming as a viable path for actually winning this damn world war zero rather than obliterating humanity.

To give but a few aspirationally crimson and admittedly very biased examples of Protocolization's possibilities.

[1] this post breaks the first rule of the glass bead game as enumerated by Aneesh:

A move is a bead. Every reply contains at most 1,000 characters, i.e. a stub equivalent. A move you are embarrassed by is better than no move. Play!

from And Yet Here We Are 🚀 ↗ · excerpt of v2

https://blyg.aneeshsathe.com/t/31fsatfshrm695fwk1zw75v7sp/

[2] Biology is the study of life. Chemistry is the study of matter. Math is the study of, well, math :P

[3] Brian Rotman is a mathematician-turned-semiotician whose books treat mathematics as a practice of writing and signs rather than a window onto timeless objects. In Signifying Nothing: The Semiotics of Zero (1987), he argues that zero arrived as a sign about other signs, a "meta-sign" marking an absence, and that this changed how Western mathematics, money, and perspective painting could imagine infinity and the vanishing point. Ad Infinitum… The Ghost in Turing's Machine (1993) goes after the idea of the endlessly repeatable act, asking what "and so on" quietly assumes about a person who counts. Mathematics as Sign: Writing, Imagining, Counting (2000) is his fullest statement. He splits the mathematical scene into a Subject who thinks, a Person who writes, and an Agent who carries out the operations, and he treats the "imaginary" in mathematics as something generated by the scripts we inscribe.

What interests me for this thread is his view of the sign as an instruction. A mathematical text, for Rotman, is less a report of facts than a set of directions: let x be, consider, continue in this way. It addresses a reader and asks them to do something, to imagine a move, run a procedure, follow a pattern out past what anyone could actually complete. The proof is a script the reader performs, and the shared understanding comes from performing it together. That is close to the glass bead game's rule that a move is a bead, and close to showing rather than telling. Symbols are choreography for another mind, and the "abstract sleepwalking" I worried about above may be what happens when we forget there is a body on the other end of the instruction.

[4] Grass btw is too neat and tidy for the wildness that's needed to get away from the digital world. It also uses a lot of water which is heretical for frivolous uses in my family :P

read the thread →

Created: Oct 28, 2026

thread

Blyg-Caster

[Blyg-Caster is a vision for a blygger client that treats Farcaster as both a source and a destination. On the input side, it reads from your Farcaster feed so that casts you care about can be pulled into a blyg as quotes, but only when you choose to, so quoting stays a deliberate act and not an automatic scrape. On the output side, it posts short summary blygs with links back to the full pieces over the protocol that was formerly Farcaster, so the writing lives on your own blyg while the conversation around it stays where your readers already are. The repo linked below is where this is taking shape.

The natural extension is to make the same loop work for other networks. Bluesky and Mastodon are the obvious next targets, since both have open protocols and friendly APIs. Twitter is theoretically possible, though the API costs make it a hard sell, and Truth Social is technically within reach but the tech is bad enough that I'd only get to it last, if ever. The goal is one client where you choose which networks to quote from and which to post summaries to, without being tied to any single platform.]

https://github.com/patwater/blyg-caster

read the thread →

Created: Oct 28, 2026

Also reading

blogroll.opml — import this list into your feed reader