Scheming on bringing the Stag Hunt to blygger... starting a stub and sharing the draft protocol below:
The Stag Hunt protocol solves a specific coordination problem: how do you get the epistemic benefits of a small, honest, in-person conversation — the kind where people actually update their views because the stakes of being wrong in front of five people you respect are different from the stakes of being wrong on Twitter — without either (a) keeping the whole thing private forever, which loses the serendipitous upside of the internet, or (b) publishing it directly, which changes what people are willing to say in the room.
The trick is a two-phase structure.
- Phase one is synchronous and closed: a small group talks under Chatham House Rules, so nobody has to pre-optimize their sentences for a public audience, and the conversation can go to the interesting, underdeveloped, maybe-wrong places that only happen when reputational risk is low.
- Phase two is asynchronous and public: someone takes the raw transcript and resynthesizes it into a single anonymous essay-voice — not a dialogue, not a summary with names attached, but a fused perspective that carries the ideas forward while stripping anything that could identify or embarrass a participant.
What gets published isn't a record of who said what; it's the residue of the conversation — worth reading on its own terms — released into public view specifically so people who weren't in the room can stumble onto it, riff on it, or connect it to something else. The closed room protects candor; the public writeup converts that candor into serendipity, without anyone having to trade one for the other.
