RSS ⧉

Pioneering Spirit (Blyg)

PAtwater

Some quick biographical context: 38, male, So Cal born, bred and still belong here, stereotypically spent a couple stints in the Bay / NYC / DC (also Philly!), once drove from Cincinnati to LA with a new employee at a crazy indie publishing venture, helped launch the CaDC, married, work as a data sophist of sorts, father of two girls (4 years and 8 months).

Rewilding Permitting Protocols

Notes from a week of sparring with Goldratt and a ghost of Ribbonfarm

Earlier this week I read a Niskanen Center piece on how a Senate permitting package could speed up geothermal, and I asked Claude what Eliyahu Goldratt's The Goal would make of it. The proposal leans on 30-day deadlines and a new ombudsman. That is the kind of fix the book's hero spends a hundred pages learning to distrust, because asking more of a system without examining the system mostly produces expediters.

So I went looking for the system, or at least for what the Government Accountability Office had written about it. The details make anyone who has worked in a public agency wince. One developer reported that some Bureau of Land Management offices accept permit materials by email while others want mailed forms with wet signatures. Developers say "exploration" to mean drilling for the resource, while BLM's regulations use the word differently, so people file the wrong application. The agency's geothermal handbooks have been in draft since at least 2022, and one Nevada office GAO describes was 60 percent vacant.

None of that is in the statute. It is the actual protocol, the one that lives in the habits of each field office, and it differs from the one in the documents. I have started calling the practice of looking at it first rewilding: finding out what is really happening before deciding what to fix.


Goldratt supplies the method. Find where throughput dies, measure the waiting separately from the working, and resist speeding up steps that are not the constraint. GAO's numbers suggest the constraint may not be where the reformers are pointing. Nominated land took 455 days on average to reach a lease sale on BLM land, and about a fifth of nominated acres were rejected because land use plans never allowed geothermal leasing in the first place. Meanwhile, approved drilling permits climbed from 7 in 2019 to 68 in 2024.

I took the same question to vgr_zirp, my reconstructed Ribbonfarm sparring partner, who rejected the premise. In his telling the permit office is rarely the constraint. The queue is a symptom of a political settlement, and speeding it up only delivers you to the wall faster. He is probably right about housing and CEQA, where the wall is a lawsuit. I am less sure he is right about geothermal on federal land, where most of what GAO describes is ambiguity, variation between offices, and too few geologists. Those are problems Goldratt knew how to work on.


Iceland offers a picture of the alternative. Parliament approves a Master Plan that sorts proposed power projects into use, on hold, or protection, and the result binds municipal land-use planning. The argument over where happens once, in public, before a developer is standing at a counter holding a form. The protocol is written down instead of rediscovered office by office. It also arrives in very large batches. One project I read about waited more than four years between reaching the steering committee and a favorable recommendation, which still needs a parliamentary vote.

Which brings me back to the wet signature. A protocol that lives in habit can be changed by a handbook, a tracker, and a decision about who is allowed to say no. A protocol that lives in a political settlement takes a different kind of work and a lot more time. I don't yet know how to tell, from the outside, which kind of wall a given permit is waiting at. That seems like a test worth someone building.

Suggested tags: permitting, geothermal, protocols, infrastructure

v2

Created: Nov 4, 2026 Most recent: Nov 4, 2026, v2