RSS ⧉

Pioneering Spirit (Blyg)

PAtwater

Some quick biographical context: 38, male, So Cal born, bred and still belong here, stereotypically spent a couple stints in the Bay / NYC / DC (also Philly!), once drove from Cincinnati to LA with a new employee at a crazy indie publishing venture, helped launch the CaDC, married, work as a data sophist of sorts, father of two girls (4 years and 8 months).

In response to
Venkatesh Rao's Blyg · Venkatesh Rao · “I wonder if we could have something like soft Lean proofs for prose, to signal a…” · item 4abe33ngtc0hr0kha70tz31czp, v1 · <https://venkateshrao.com/blyg/f/4abe33ngtc0hr0kha70tz31czp/> · retrieved Nov 20, 2026

I wonder if we could have something like soft Lean proofs for prose, to signal a certain level of coherence and conceptual integrity. Many kinds of formal prose (legal, technical) are already close. Operations like fact-checking already exist, and grammar checking is a kind of validation. So why not semantic validation?

from Venkatesh Rao's Blyg ↗ · snapshot of v1

Something like modal logic? You know it wouldnt be that hard to have an ai verifier go through and check for coherence, going beyond logic. On a secant, I'd propose a sophistry based approach and will add this to my list of fafo AI experiments.

Oh also see keith devlins book goodbye descartes.

v2

Created: Nov 20, 2026 Most recent: Nov 20, 2026, v2