{"blyg":"0.4","id":"5e3tjzxhxv3gb8wg5h368pbs9x","kind":"thread","origin":"https://blyg.pioneeringspirit.xyz/","page":"t/5e3tjzxhxv3gb8wg5h368pbs9x/","author":{"name":"PAtwater","url":"https://blyg.pioneeringspirit.xyz"},"created":"2026-11-14T05:34:18Z","updated":"2026-11-14T05:34:18Z","version":1,"content_md":"Are the much derided Google+ circles an idea whose time finally has come? In a common fabric world where trust is tied to data and protocols guide where critical information flows, it seems that posts could be published not to the world wide web but rather a mesoscale alternative customized based on a plain text instruction. \n\n[Common fabric is an approach to computing where trust travels with the data itself, and protocols, rather than platforms, govern where information is allowed to flow. Instead of defaulting to the open web or a single company's walled garden, people can share within a space shaped to the context, which is the mesoscale between private and public. The reasoning is laid out in [why Common Fabric](https://github.com/patwater/Common-fabric-labs/blob/main/docs/why.md).] \n\nGoogle+ circles were 1) very annoying to create in that they required you to go through all your friends and add them manually to different \"circles\" like high school or college or work or a sport or another hobby 2) conceptually quite clever -- in sum a very OG googley approach that was a bit awkward software engineer geek vibe albeit good natured and friendly. They remind me in that way of wikis which were cool in concept though outside of headline examples like wikipedia really generally poorly maintained. \n\nLLMs have changed that. Tons of people, particularly the sort playing around in the Thicket, use Karpathy style personal knowledge wikis. AI easily acts as a sort of super librarian tagging and organizing and querying all that information you send its way. Very helpul. It strikes me that AI could serve a similar curation function  for Google+ style circles on things like the Thicket where you share ideas in larger or smaller circles. \n\nMany people have ideas that they wouldn't want on the wide web with its dark forest dynamics and potential for problems, particularly if you present an attractive attack surface for whatever reason. Instead consider the alternative of a set of overlapping albeit distinct circles of people that you'd want to potentially share with. \n\n","content_html":"<p>Are the much derided Google+ circles an idea whose time finally has come? In a common fabric world where trust is tied to data and protocols guide where critical information flows, it seems that posts could be published not to the world wide web but rather a mesoscale alternative customized based on a plain text instruction.</p>\n<p>[<span class=\"blyg-tk-gen\">Common fabric is an approach to computing where trust travels with the data itself, and protocols, rather than platforms, govern where information is allowed to flow. Instead of defaulting to the open web or a single company's walled garden, people can share within a space shaped to the context, which is the mesoscale between private and public. The reasoning is laid out in <a href=\"https://github.com/patwater/Common-fabric-labs/blob/main/docs/why.md\">why Common Fabric</a>.</span>]</p>\n<p>Google+ circles were 1) very annoying to create in that they required you to go through all your friends and add them manually to different &quot;circles&quot; like high school or college or work or a sport or another hobby 2) conceptually quite clever -- in sum a very OG googley approach that was a bit awkward software engineer geek vibe albeit good natured and friendly. They remind me in that way of wikis which were cool in concept though outside of headline examples like wikipedia really generally poorly maintained.</p>\n<p>LLMs have changed that. Tons of people, particularly the sort playing around in the Thicket, use Karpathy style personal knowledge wikis. AI easily acts as a sort of super librarian tagging and organizing and querying all that information you send its way. Very helpul. It strikes me that AI could serve a similar curation function  for Google+ style circles on things like the Thicket where you share ideas in larger or smaller circles.</p>\n<p>Many people have ideas that they wouldn't want on the wide web with its dark forest dynamics and potential for problems, particularly if you present an attractive attack surface for whatever reason. Instead consider the alternative of a set of overlapping albeit distinct circles of people that you'd want to potentially share with.</p>\n","content_hash":"sha256:818e5ee409e86f2d616ff299cafb580ffc03db94ebf97df4646cf2a147345bb1","media":[],"transclusions":[],"generated":[{"sources":[],"model":"claude-sonnet-5-5","at":"2026-11-14T05:22:48Z"}],"changelog":[{"version":1,"at":"2026-11-14T05:34:18Z","note":null}]}