{"blyg":"0.4","id":"01y9r1a6xj5yy93qsm3segxn87","kind":"thread","origin":"https://blyg.pioneeringspirit.xyz/","page":"t/01y9r1a6xj5yy93qsm3segxn87/","author":{"name":"PAtwater","url":"https://blyg.pioneeringspirit.xyz"},"created":"2026-11-03T04:53:05Z","updated":"2026-11-03T04:57:13Z","version":1,"content_md":"![[28xxasbg7egzbw5kexxv1c3ms8]]\n\nStub works! Welcome to the thicket. \n\nMy motivating example was fish counts using sonar. Realistically both the human expert annotator and the AI are wrong compared to what's going on in the world. I agree there already is a lot of and will be more automation. I wonder how much will require use case specific codes. Reality has a surprising amount of detail and all that. \n","content_html":"<blockquote class=\"blyg-transclusion\" data-blyg-id=\"28xxasbg7egzbw5kexxv1c3ms8\" data-blyg-version=\"2\" data-blyg-origin=\"https://blyg.sampsoftware.net/\">\n<blockquote class=\"blyg-transclusion\" data-blyg-id=\"56dt4gdjp4enbrs0vr9z7fc1ty\" data-blyg-version=\"1\" data-blyg-origin=\"https://blyg.pioneeringspirit.xyz/\">\n<p>A loose thought: when will human experts stop being the gold standard for ground truthing niche classification problems? That's already shifted in somewhat in domains like radiology but even there there's issues with classifying in the wild of lots of hospital with messy sensors. Is this something that will generalize in the coming years with AI?</p>\n\n</blockquote>\n<p>In some domains, plenty of it will be automated - a lot of it already is! AI broadly defined will precategorize everything easy - or things that are hard for humans but easy for machines - and the human will classify everything that is left.</p>\n<p>I think of the old 50s sitcoms - the I Love Lucys etc - where e.g. Lucy gets a job on the candy inspection line and has to review every candy (eventually she falls behind and eats them, for comedic effect). Today a camera reviews them all as they pass at high speed.</p>\n<p>But someone is setting the criteria, creating cutoffs, reviewing edge cases, etc.</p>\n<p>Even &quot;it has shifted in radiology&quot; - when did the shift start? When AI started classifying? When easy access to imaging machines created false color images, or on a particular layer of a 3D scan.</p>\n<p>(A special note - my first stub, let's see if I did it right.)</p>\n\n</blockquote>\n<p>Stub works! Welcome to the thicket.</p>\n<p>My motivating example was fish counts using sonar. Realistically both the human expert annotator and the AI are wrong compared to what's going on in the world. I agree there already is a lot of and will be more automation. I wonder how much will require use case specific codes. Reality has a surprising amount of detail and all that.</p>\n","content_hash":"sha256:09b1d08e1f814911cb6cd912eadb9199bfce7bc94d92915f06d2363f423fb92e","media":[],"transclusions":[{"id":"28xxasbg7egzbw5kexxv1c3ms8","version":2,"origin":"https://blyg.sampsoftware.net/","cited":{"source":"Samp Software and other things","author":"Chris Samp","excerpt":"A loose thought: when will human experts stop being the gold standard for ground…","url":"https://blyg.sampsoftware.net/t/28xxasbg7egzbw5kexxv1c3ms8/","retrieved":"2026-11-03T04:57:13Z"}}],"stub_of":{"origin":"https://blyg.sampsoftware.net/","id":"28xxasbg7egzbw5kexxv1c3ms8","version":2,"cited":{"source":"Samp Software and other things","author":"Chris Samp","excerpt":"A loose thought: when will human experts stop being the gold standard for ground…","url":"https://blyg.sampsoftware.net/t/28xxasbg7egzbw5kexxv1c3ms8/","retrieved":"2026-11-03T04:57:13Z"}},"changelog":[{"version":1,"at":"2026-11-03T04:57:13Z","note":null}]}